Wednesday, December 5, 2012

What is SparkNotes Missing?


I have always found the concept of SparkNotes very interesting. At times it can be very helpful, but I also can’t help frustrated when dealing with SparkNotes and my future profession as a teacher. As a future teacher, I am definitely a part of this activity system, along with other teachers and students.  As a future teacher, I have goals for my students. Obviously I want them to gain knowledge and understanding for the literature and be able to take something away from the unit. Some of my future students may not care much about the bigger, but rather are concerned with getting a decent grade and moving from the class.  In the classroom, students substitute one material for another because they believe them to be equivalent. They use site in place of the novel and read it to just gain enough of information to get a good grade or pass a test, but what are they missing when they do this? Just with the time I have spent with my current students during my field experience at Central High School, I can tell that SparkNotes is a big aid for most students. It is obvious though that some students abuse this source.

There are some beneficial reasons for students to use SparkNotes. For example, it can be a good aid to refer to as the student is reading the actual or assigned text. When doing this, it can be used to gain of better/deeper understanding for the text. SparkNotes can be more reader friendly. It gets to the point, in simple language, cutting out detail, and giving the reader the main points.

On the other hand, there are some negatives. What are students missing when they pick SparkNotes over the whole text?  When looking at the section below and comparing that to the section in the novel, there are some dramatic differences. The biggest difference being that this one paragraph section is “equivalent” to 6 pages in the novel. When looking at that fact alone, you know some of the details are being cut out. For example, dialog is completely cut out in the SparkNotes summary, along with some major plot point. One of the plot points that you don’t get from reading this section of SparkNotes is the dynamic between Elizabeth, Caroline, and Darcy. In the novel, the reader learns that Caroline Bingley really doesn't like Elizabeth because Caroline has feelings for Darcy and she can tell that Darcy has feelings for Elizabeth. This is a complicated love triangle and it built throughout the novel and yet we get no explanation of in the SparkNotes section. Now although this may seem like a small detail, Caroline becomes a bit of the antagonist and this would be important for the students to identify.  Without her role in the story, there would be far less conflict and no explanation as to why Darcy and Elizabeth have the relationship they do.
“That night, while Elizabeth visits Jane, the Bingley sisters poke fun at the Bennett’s. Darcy and Mr. Bingley defend them, though Darcy concedes, first, that he would not want his sister ever to go out on such a walking expedition and, second, that the Bennets’ lack of wealth and family make them poor marriage prospects. When Elizabeth returns to the room, the discussion turns to Darcy’s library at his ancestral home of Pemberley and then to Darcy’s opinions on what constitutes an “accomplished woman.” After he and Bingley list the attributes that such a woman would possess, Elizabeth declares that she “never saw such capacity, and taste, and application, and elegance, as you describe, united, and implying that Darcy is far too demanding.”
Although the section from SparkNotes is written in more of a plain style than the original text, there are still elements of the official style. I believe that the website does this to establish some type of credibility. If the site was in “too plain” of style, I believe people would be far less likely to use the site as often as they do. For example, sentences in the above section like “Darcy’s opinions on what constitutes an accomplished woman” or “Bingley list the attributes that such a woman would possess.” These sentences could be put in even more of a plainer form, yet they keep a sense of formality. Also, there are different types of sentence combining strategies that are used that also add an element of the official style.

Overall I think that SparkNotes is a good resource for students to use as an aid, but there is no way to make sure that students aren't using it as a complete substitution. Although it would probably be very difficult for teacher to make it impossible for students to do well on quizzes, assignments, or exams just from using SparkNotes, they can try. For example, a teacher can look at SparkNotes and when they create a quiz or exam, make sure that they place questions on it that you would have to read the actual novel to understand. So then, the question becomes what is the importance of literature? Is it an important thing that students read the original novel versus SparkNotes version? Or can they get from SparkNotes all that they need, enough information to pass a test and get a decent grade. My answer to this is the original text is important and students are missing out on valuable information by ignoring that and only choosing to look at SparkNotes. 

Kacie Burke

The Truth and Nothing but the Plain Truth



When Richard Neill posted his comment on Facebook addressing the “lies” that Tampons companies have been selling since his childhood, it’s hardly likely he expected things to go as far as they did. A commercial specifically calling him out came as a response from the company, and soon thereafter news articles followed, creeping up to address the new viral campaign. This video has many people talking about the nature of sanitary pad advertising, and while some people are taking a strict analytical stance in response to it, others, such as Jennifer O’Connell from the online division of Dublin’s leading newspaper The Irish Times, aren’t going to let the opportunity to have a little fun with journalism pass them by. Reviewing the world’s (arguably) first funny advertisement for Tampons isn’t a job that just anyone would take on, but that’s just what Jennifer O’Connell did. In this witty critique of BodyForm’s newest Tampon-selling scheme, O’Connell succeeded in not only portraying the hilarious devices used by BodyForm in their Truth about Periods campaign, but also brought to the table her own amusing takes on the issue: Why can’t the general public handle the reality of women’s menstruation?

O’Connell starts her article with a paragraph warning her audience of what was to come:
“This is a column about the stuff the advertising industry wants to protect you from. That’s right: we’re talking about the messy reality of womanhood. The word “period” may feature. Cutsey euphemisms such as Aunty Flo, The Painters and That Time of the Month won’t. Neither will the suggestion that the shedding of the uterine lining is the ideal opportunity to go ice-skating in a pair of tight white jeans.”
She then adds, “So if you’re squeamish about that kind of thing, move right along to the other pages.” After a paragraph break, O’Connell good-naturedly asks, “Still here?” as if addressing an audience that she can communicate with but not see. It all creates a lead in that instantly grabs attention. O’Connell addresses her readers directly, challenging them to face what she’s about to write about, but keeps her tone at all times laid back, joking, and even familiar, as if she is simply conversing with a group of friends, rather than addressing a nation at large. She is, after all, addressing a nation as a whole, as The Irish Times is Ireland’s leading newspaper agency, comparable to what The New York Times is in America. And, although she is writing for an online-only blog feature of the agency’s site, it gets the attention that a national newsource would be expected to get (with ninety recommendations on Facebook, forty-two tweets, and twenty-nine shares on Google’s Blog community showing up at the top of article). It does seem though that the audience O’Connell is targeting is much smaller than that which is available to her -- half the size, in fact. O’Connell often refers to ‘men’ throughout her article in the passive sense, as if assuming no man is reading her article anyway. So, by her estimation the audience reading this article consists of women only, and not even just women, but women between the ages of twelve and menopause -- I mean to say, those who menstruate. At times she does stray from this, posing questions for her imaginary public that address more than just the female population: “Why are we so squeamish about something that will affect half the population once a month, for at least part of their lives?”

Neill's Original Comment

Some of these questions, she goes on to answer later in her article. Throughout her article she follows the history of sanitary pad advertising and it’s hits and misses with honesty in commercials. One in particular, she covers knowing that most of the people in the audience will be familiar with the commercials, but not as familiar with the background information:
“A 2010 ad for the American brand U by Kotex parodying the industry was more successful. “How do I feel about my period?” the actress in the ad asks. “I love it . . . Sometimes I just want to run on a beach. Unusually, by the third day, I just want to dance.” Sadly, the ad was rewarded for its candour with instant banning by three US TV networks. It had to be re-edited to replace the word “vagina” with the expression “down there” – and even then, two of the three networks still refused to run it.”
She covers the history of Tampon advertising, all the way from “a new freedom, comfort, convenience” in the 1930s, to Kotex’s “by the third day, I just want to dance,” pulling information from all sources, and creating a collage of failed advertising and comparing it to what she calls “[a] break with two of the major conventions for public discussion of the female menstrual cycle.” O’Connell compares the simple facts of Tampon advertisements in the past, to what this one does differently, without ever slipping out of her conversational tone.

Really, this article doesn’t seem to slip into what one would call the Official Style at all. Any time that she even gets close to toeing the line of “Formal Writing”, it’s used in a humorous way, as if she’s mocking the experts that talk about this subject without an ounce of humor. This can be seen very well in this quote about the differences in the reaction that people have when discussing periods:
“Women, I’ve noticed, have no problem discussing our menstrual cycles with each other. We compare notes about tears shed, or quantities of Maltesers consumed; we even prevail upon each other for tampon supplies when we’re caught short. So if we can laugh about our periods, why can’t advertisers?”

She speaks here of women and their periods as if it is a field of study (we all minor in menstruation perhaps?), and this is the only place in the article where you see sentences rambling on for several lines, and using combining of sentences to continue a thought. There is also a certain high-brow air in the voice used here that isn’t present elsewhere in the article, as if she is deeming herself the forefront of experts on this subject.

So, is O’Connell’s critique successful? She’s honest, plain, and funny, and still all the while, proving that she knows exactly what she’s talking about. I think few people would argue that her article fails to achieve what it set out to do -- namely, bring this issue to the forefront of people’s minds.

A humorous campaign from Pakistan in 2010 in response to WikiLeaks.
-Lauren Ihrke

Tuesday, December 4, 2012

Plainly, the Name is Bond, James Bond


Vol. 12, No.17 of LIFE, a registered trademark of TIME Inc.

James Bond is back.

 “50 Years of James Bond” was published on September 14th, 2012, and the 112 page special will be on the stands until 12/14/12.  As an avid fan of the film series, having started watching Bond at 13 during the Spike TV holiday marathon, I of course snatched up one of these bad boys when they came out, the oh-so-classic image of Sean Connery encouraging me to be “On the Run with 007, from Dr. No to Skyfall.”  I was curious as to what I would find in terms of prose style for this adventure.  The Ian Fleming novels were dense, intense, description-rich blocks of text; the films ranged from Roger Moore’s one-liners to Daniel Craig’s cold blooded, unsmiling license to kill.  In this featurette on the world’s favorite spy, you can relish plain style prose that narrates the epic history of the world’s favorite spy.  With glossy pictures, bullet-pointed facts, “Life Magazine’s traditional journalistic style,” (quoted from http://borg.com/2012/09/26/life-magazine-looks-at-50-years-of-james-bond-from-dr-no-to-skyfall/), and trivia aplenty, this Pussy Galore style romp is a display of the simple sophistication that is the Bond legacy. 


The viewers of James Bond movies are typically of a male majority, old and young, and tend to be fans of spy/action films, the occasional classic film buff taking a seat in the audience.  As this quote from page 184 of The James Bond Phenomenon: A Critical Reader by Christoph Lindner reveals, though, defining the viewing demographic of the Bond films is not as simple as it seems. 

“...in the 1960s, the audience for the Bond films had consisted, in the main, of adolescents and young adults’, whereas by 1979, ‘the audience consisted mainly of parents and pre-adolescent children.’  While this may well be true, that parenthetical ‘in the main’ covers a multitude of exceptions.”

The Bond audience is far-reaching, not just in terms of viewer demographics, but also in terms of geographic and generational expanse.  Opening worldwide, celebrating its 50th year, and dividing its release between MGM and Sony, James Bond needs to be prepared for the entire world to take a peek inside of this magazine. 

LIFE also has a readership to be aware of.  “Life magazine was one of the most important magazines published in the United States. One study revealed that in a given thirteen-week period in 1950, ‘about half of all Americans, ten years and older, had seen one or more copies’ of the magazine” (http://www.h-net.org/reviews/showrev.php?id=7096).   


“James Bond is back.  It’s a slogan as old as 1963, when the second film in the famous series, From Russia with Love, opened, and it is being voiced again to welcome Skyfall to your neighborhood IMAX.  Bond fans, of which you are one, exult, and others marvel that the superspy is still with us; 50 years after Dr. No opened, 23 moves in all.  (Well, not quite all, as will be explained in our pages: There were two “unofficial” feature films made, plus a television adaptation of a Bond novel, Casino Royale, that aired way back in 1954.)”

Flesch-Kincaid Reading Ease: 76.6
Average Grade Level: 7.0
Word Count: 100
Words per Sentence: 16.7

At precisely the average reading level of the United States, the first paragraph of “50 Years of James Bond” presents itself as clear and concise, using metabasis to encourage readers to move past the first page.  There’s no wordy introduction, there is no skirting around the facts; there is just cold blooded statement.  The first sentence  “James Bond is back” is aschematiston in Bond fashion.  In terms of Bond trivia, it’s important to know that “James Bond will be back in...” was the screen flashed at the end of (almost) every Bond film (that, or “James Bond will return in...”)  So, this simple opening plays directly into the activity system this article was written for.   Another important reason to put it out there and lead with the fact that “James Bond is back” is because 2012 saw the release of Skyfall.  MGM needed the world to know that “James Bond is back” so that they could sell enough tickets to pay for their multi-million dollar movie. 

The article promptly shifts into a informal “you,” addressing the readers directly.  “...Bond fans, of which you are one...”  The article uses Skyfall and IMAX theaters as exemplum of how and where you, yes you, will find yourself being a Bond fan.  This shameless promotion is effective in getting the reader to visualize themselves heading to that theater, buying a large popcorn, reclining in their IMAX seat, and living the newest Bond installment, and it also familiarizes the reader, making the reader feel chummy with the LIFE featurette and comfortable with the publication’s plain prose. 

In terms of punctuation, there appears to be some looser construction within this opening paragraph.  “Bond fans, of which you are one, exult, and others marvel that the superspy is still with us; 50 years after Dr. No opened, 23 moves in all.”  The semicolon usage in this sentence does not connect two independent clauses, and it is is not serving as a “super comma” within a list.  But will LIFE readers and Bond fans notice?  Probably not.  (http://theoatmeal.com/comics/semicolon).  This semicolon sentence is swiftly followed by parenthesis.  Both of these things contribute to the plain style of the piece, and cater to the audience’s desire for a fast, entertaining read akin to the gritty, frothy Bond flicks they love. 

Concluding the parenthesis is the phrase “way back.”   For younger readers and Bond fans, this serves as casual language; for older readers and Bond fans, this serves as hyperbole and sarcasm.  “Waaaay back in 1954.”  Some Bond fans were becoming parents in 1954; 1954 feels like yesterday.  “Way back” is a reminder of where Bond has been, but also an emphasis on how present Bond still is in today’s life.

All of these things add up to create an opening paragraph that is conversational, accessible, and tends to the old and young readers alike, mimicking the style of the Bond films themselves.


“If the movie was, ummm, stupid--and it surely was--many of its lead actors and other personnel were anything but.  One of its five credited directors was John Huston, who back in the early 1960s had wondered about making a Bond movie starring Cary Grant.  Woody Allen not only acted as one of the ersatz Bonds, he also contributed some (uncredited) writing, as did Huston and Orson Welles, who also costarred.  Niven, at left with Angela Scoular and above in the white suit with Joanna Pettet in the foreground, was an Oscar winner.  We have mentioned Deborah Kerr, and then there was Peter Sellers and Jacqueline Bisset as Giovanna Goodthighs and William Holden and Burt Bacharach’s music and...”

Flesch-Kincaid Reading Ease: 54
Average Grade Level: 10
Word Count: 120
Words per Sentence: 20

Flush with exemplum, this excerpt explores the celebrity attached with the Bond films--even that of the unloved bastard parody.  I chose this part of the magazine to look at almost explicitly for the line “...the move was, ummm, stupid...” which for Bond fans is a bit of apodixis.  It is unlikely that anyone watching the 1960s Casino Royale walked away thinking, “Now there was a great Hollywood classic!”  Following the “ummm, stupid,” the writer launches into the film’s extensive cast, intimating that the film should have been better, yet somehow tripped and tumbled down a hill, coming to a stop in the land of poorly executed parody.  I think this excerpt is important in catering to the older Bond fans and LIFE readers, because it explores an event from “way back”  in the 1960s, and lists celebrities from an older generation. 

“Was Q quitting?  It seemed he might be when the MI6 quartermaster, played for the 17th time by Desmond Llewelyn, introduced Bond to a somewhat younger man he was training, played by John Cleese.  ‘If you're Q, does that make him R?’  The question is never answered, but Llewelyn was killed in the aforementioned automobile accident shortly after wrapping the film, and Cleese played the Q--or R-- role in the final Brosnan film.”

Flesch-Kincaid Reading Ease 68.2
Average Grade Level: 9.1
Word Count: 75
Words per Sentence: 18.8

This blurb opens with the anthypophora of “Was Q quitting?” It then jumps into the Bond archives to discuss the nuances of Q (or R) and the death of Desmond Llewelyn.  The notion that Cleese was “R” is a bit of assumptio on the writer’s part.  Who qualifies as Q?  Was John Cleese allowed to be Q officially, or was Desmond Llewellyn the one, true Q, yet to have a successor?  I chose to look at this passage because the presence of Q within the film is vital to this year’s Skyfall; not only “James Bond is back,” but “Q is back” too.  The sentence “a somewhat younger man...played by John Cleese” caters to the Bond culture as well; in the newest film, Q is played by an actor in his 30s, and is presented throughout the film as perhaps even younger than that. (Here it’s suggested that “Bond purists” will be upsetted by the introduction of a Q younger than Bond, a deviation from the original Fleming works: http://screenrant.com/james-bond-skyfall-cast-ben-whishaw-kofi-141185/). The prose in this passage subtly hints at the discussions within the Bond community about Q and Q’s role within the franchise.  It’s things like this that delight the Bond fan in me.  The reference is simple and simply put, but the allusion to the fact that Skyfall is debuting the first “official” Q since the Brosnan era is important and relevant to the fact that “James Bond is back.”

50 years and 23 films later, I think this LIFE featurette is doing a fair job of appealing to the established audiences at play, Bond fans and LIFE readers, while drumming up interest in the newest installment.  As I had hoped going into it, the prose is like the films: simple, fast-paced, and direct.  The piece is effective at introducing nuances of the Bond franchise in an understated way, and it doesn’t crowd the piece with unnecessary words and explanation.  Ultimately, the prose used within “50 Years of James Bond” is like the man himself: a blunt instrument.  James Bond is back.

~Kali Brokaw