Tuesday, December 11, 2012

Just Let Me Know Ahead of Time

When I was a kid there really wasn’t such a thing as internet. That meant that everyone published had to go through the process of submission and publication. Writers had to have their work edited and Okayed by editors and publishers before it would see the light of day.

Today this is not the case.

Anyone has the ability to become “published” instantly. What I mean by “published” is that the work—a Facebook status, a Tweet, a blog entry about a trip to Seattle—is online and can be seen by more than say, eight people. Now I don’t mean to imply that everything “published” is total crap. In fact, a poem posted on a blog could have more reads (and more acclaim) than a poem read by all the subscribers of the North American Review. (Nothing against that magazine by the way.) The point is that we all have the power to put ourselves out there for all to see. All we need is internet access and an email address. Not only can we display our ideas and writings easily but nothing and no one hinders us from doing so. We can create worlds that suit us and at the same time attract audiences to see what’s up. I believe that if we don’t deceive them and tell them what they are getting into when they join up with our personal creative guilds, we can be very successful.

In this essay I will be examining one particular article titled “A Hierarchy of Hypocrites” by Bill Simmons, the editor-in-chief of Grantland, an online sports magazine affiliated with ESPN. The article is (mostly) about the commissioner of the National Football League Roger Goodell, although the commissioners of the NBA, MLB and NHL are discussed, too. Simmons criticizes Goodell for various decisions he made around the time the article was written, October 2012, and suggests we oust him. The article is a hodgepodge. Fans’ emails and YouTube clips are seen on the page as well as Vegas picks for upcoming NFL games.

First, let’s get a little insight into Bill Simmons and Grantland. Grantland is an online sports magazine that Simmons runs, and it’s very clear that he runs it. While there is a gaggle of recurring writers Simmons’ articles always receive a link on the ESPN homepage, conveniently located next to a black and white picture of the man himself. Simmons is also the host of the B.S. Report, a podcast also linked on ESPN’s homepage.

On the Grantland website Simmons has his own link at the top of the page and the magazine’s other authors fall under the label “Contributors.”

Well now, have I led you to believe the Simmons is a narcissistic, megalomaniac writer? Heck, if I was the editor-in-chief of an online journal I would want to make a big deal of it too. Plus, it is not like the other authors of this journal have their pieces hidden behind spam. It's not like they require secret codes to access. Their pages are a click of the mouse away. My reason for showing how much Simmons’ image and name are attached to Grantland is this; by increasing his own identity and visibility within the magazine we are allowed to understand that what Bill Simmons wants Bill Simmons will have. We can ascertain, from the very first site of his picture on ESPN, that whatever there is to read, it was allowed to cross the finish line into publication by Simmons.

On October 19, 2012, Simmons published the article into which we will now dive. Titled “A Hierarchy of Hypocrites” the article begins with the subtitle “The Sports Guy [Simmons] wishes we could run our sports commissioners out of office and makes his Week 7 picks.” Clearly no subjectivity will exist in this article. If we are looking for research-based and opposition-answering rhetoric, look away we should. But really, what kind of sports article would be written in that way? Don’t we, when reading such articles, expect to gather the opinions of the writers themselves? Aren’t we prepared for objectivity? The first paragraph of the article is as follows:

The first paragraph of the article is as follows:
This wasn't the best morning for Roger Goodell. Hours after former Viking Jimmy Kennedy practically ran out of ways to call the NFL's commissioner a “liar,” Goodell announced that he would be recusing himself from hearing the Saints' latest bounty appeal. Taking over? Wait a second … good God, that's Paul Tagliabue's music! Can you remember another commissioner having his objectivity questioned so vociferously that he had to enlist his former boss to clean up his mess? Me neither.
Having no knowledge whatsoever of American football we can still gather that someone named Roger Goodell is the commissioner of the NFL. We can assume that for whatever reason the commissioner of the NFL is the highest position attainable. We can also gather that Paul Tagliabue used to be the commissioner and likely preceded Goodell in that position. All of these things happen to be true, but what about Jimmy Kennedy? So, he’s a Viking, but why would he call the commissioner a liar? What did the Saints do exactly? Simmons provides a link to Kennedy’s comments on Goodell but the rest of this information requires our own research to understand. There is a lot of knowledge and background information Simmons expects you to already know in this article.

A little later Simmons says, “And then there's Gary Bruce Bettman, the serial killer of the National Hockey League, someone who keeps murdering games and seasons without being caught. He's only missing a catchy/creepy nickname like the Zamboni Killer or the Canadian Bogeyman.” We can deduce that Bettman is the commissioner of the NHL, but Simmons refers to Bettman as a “serial killer” for specific reasons not mentioned. Simmons is referencing the cancellation of half of the 1994-95 season as well as the entire 2004-05 season. Bettman was head of the League during both those labor stoppages.

If Simmons wants to expect his audience to be up to speed with the current events in the sports world and have a somewhat intimate knowledge of the game, fine. It’s his magazine. We don’t have to read it. Let’s go back to earlier in this essay, when it seemed the Simmons was on the verge of appearing narcissistic to us. This narcissism would be achieved if he expected us to know as much as sports as he does and blew past anyone who didn’t live up to his standards. Simmons is redeemed because of two things: the humor of this piece and the accessibility of it.

Simmons describes a notion of Goodell’s hypocrisy and follows it with a funny jab: “Translation: This dude is a H-Y-P-O-C-R-I-T-E.”

He follows this judgment with the clever paragraph:
If you noticed, Goodell never responded — not even after Fujita called him “condescending” and “extremely desperate,” then complained about Goodell's “absolute abuse of the power that's been afforded to the Commissioner.” By continuing to trade shots with Fujita, Goodell would have inadvertently broken the golden rule of hip-hop: Thou shalt never beef down. And after word trickled out last weekend that Fujita had suffered a potentially career-ending neck injury, there was little chance Goodell would fire back. Even Stern during his swaggerlicious apex wouldn't have feuded with a badly injured player.
Simmons made up a word!—a fact which he acknowledges in the side panel of the article. Why not?

The second point to make is the accessibility of this piece. This may seem like contradictory on my part since I’ve already shown that Simmons demands prior sports knowledge from his writers. That is still true, but what I mean by accessibility is that this article can be enjoyed by people who don’t necessarily understand everything that is going on. Simmons provides links, YouTube clips and “even Brick killed a guy.” As much as this article is for those who are well versed in the people, places and goings-on in sports today, this article is for casual sports fans who want a laugh. The prose Simmons creates is not near academically sound, clocking in at the grade level of 8.0, not including the texts of fans’ emails, but the goal of this article is not to comply with the expectations of academia. So we see.

Let’s go back to the paragraph starting with “this wasn’t the best morning.” Look for the sentence containing Paul Tagliabue. It reads, “Wait a second … good God, that's Paul Tagliabue's music!” Someone who has never watched a World Wrestling Federation match can both laugh and wonder at this sentence, and thus it perfectly emphasizes my point. Isn’t that funny or weird, the idea of your old boss coming through a door—possibly smoke-filled, at least in my fantasy—to music to clean up some mess left by your current boss? It can be funny without the specific knowledge of entertainment wrestling.

Simmons’ article is written in one of the plainest styles—academically speaking—a legitimate adult author can use and still be respected. But he needs to write in this way because it suits the humor of his style and because it has the power to attract an audience. Simmons’ objectivity can be forgiven because it’s clear from the get-go what the intentions of this article are, and the brashness and ballsiness of the article can be allowed because, after all, it’s his magazine and because the day after this article hit the internet Goodell could have become the nicest and most loved man in the NFL thanks to some redeeming action. Anything could change and so a writer must go all out to be heard in a world where people are clamoring for opinions and ready for the next change in the sports world. This world of Sports sees many punches and Simmons delivers his own, his way. And what can I say except write on, sir. We are better for knowing ahead of time what you are all about.
By Matthew T. Bauman

"It's Not a Matter of Time; It's Just a Matter of Timing."




Music is something that most people agree is an important part of their lives. At its best, a song can completely change the way in which you view the world, and at its worst it’s background noise to make silent situations more bearable. But no matter what sort of impact the music makes on you, there seems to be a habit currently in fashion that we don’t really listen to the music we hear. For years, you may listen to a song and love it, only to find out later that it’s about something completely different than you had originally thought (or, at least, if you listen to music like my mom that’s what happens). So why exactly are the lyrics so important? Some people don’t think they are, but in a really good song, the lyrics can be a maze of hidden truths and opinions, liable to alter not only your view of the world, but the way in which you act within the world as well.


“Timelines” off of Motion City Soundtrack’s fifth studio album Go is in some ways in line with the style of music that the Minneapolis-based band has become known for in the past. The song covers singer Justin Pierre’s past struggles with social phobias and drug abuse, and is written in their familiar style of fast-paced lyrics and pop-punk melodies. But there are also many things about this song that are dramatically different from what the band has released in the past. This song is much more honest than what Pierre has previously attempted, and this, by his own admission, was something he struggled with deeply. What he did come up with in the end though is what could very easily be one of their best pieces released thus far.


The song is slung through with hypophora and rhetorical questions, weaving the story of singer Pierre’s experiences in life between the questions “Was it a matter of time?” and “Do you ever wonder how you got to here?” The first question is answered throughout implicitly, and then is addressed directly in the second chorus when he states, “Someone said, / ‘It's not a matter of time, it's just a matter of timing.’” This play on words is something seen quite commonly in Motion City Soundtrack songs. The change from time as the basic idea to the gerund form is a small change as far as a difference of letters goes, but it is a very significant change in the meanings of the two phrases. The first is pessimistic and lacks any sign of hope; it implies that only bad things could be in store for the future. The second phrase, however, holds only hope for the future. Saying something is a matter of timing is to imply conscious action by the speaker. While the first phrase seems to be referring back to the poor decisions of the speaker’s life (drug use), the second phrase suggests that things can be done right (that life can improve) if the speaker only chooses his actions carefully.

The second question of the song, “Do you ever wonder how you got to here?” is posed in the song as a rhetorical question. It is repeated several times throughout the second half of the song, but the question is never directly answered. Instead, it’s left open-ended as something for the listeners to ponder. The idea is also added to throughout the song as Pierre plays with ideas of time and cognition. In the two verses directly following the first usage of this question, all of the lines seem to play with the idea that the line suggests:

“Branded, marked, and paper thin,
This angry saint went marching in
To war with scores of ninety proof;
Found nothing but the ugly truth.
The decade of wastage an instant,
And that’s where I wanted to be.

Woke up feeling 35
Though grateful that I’m still alive.
Another chance at normalcy --
To chase the dream but now it seems
That days run away like wild horses over the hills.”

The first of these verses describes the beginning of the downward spiral. The line, “Branded, marked and paper thin,” is an example of scesis onomaton. What it’s really describing is the state of being that the speaker was in at the time, having already struggled with drugs and social disorders. He was branded and marked by what he’d gone through in the past, and he had little protection against emotional harm -- paper thin. He then describes his struggle with alcohol abuse as a war against ninety proof (synecdoche), coming back to the idea of time passing with, “The decade of wastage an instant.”

There is also a very important allusion in this song to an older song by the same band, released on their third studio album in 2007. The song “Last Night” off of that album was written while Pierre was still very much-so struggling with his drug and alcohol problems, and contained a pseudo-prayer expressing the hopelessness that he was feeling at the time.

“My body aches, it heaves, it shakes
All somersaults through so-called art
And I still don't know exactly who I am
I never will, amen.”

Here Pierre doesn’t leave any room for things changing with time. He seems only to believe that he is destined to fail, and that he could never discover those things which he so desperately wishes to know. In “Timelines” however, he addresses those lines with a changed perspective, stating:

“Take it in and hold on while you can;
All the destruction will one day end,
And you'll finally know exactly who you are.
It's just a matter of timing.”

It seems that opinions between 2007 and now have changed dramatically for Justin Pierre. With improved health -- both physically and mentally -- has come a new perspective on his life, and although he’s still conscious of the mistakes he’s made in his life (taking the whole first half of the song to describe them), his words show a definite knowledge that things are improving and will continue to do so. The whole tone of this song is different than what has been seen in the past. This album, instead of being a roller coaster of ups and down -- failures and successes -- seems always to be heading upward. It takes the darkness of past experience, and layers it with hope for the future.
For a band that attracts listeners who’ve gone through the same or similar situations, this is a change that will make definite impressions on its listeners. Motion City Soundtrack is a pop-punk styled band that attracts the usual listeners mostly in their teens and twenties, but they’ve also tapped into different groups as well. It’s not uncommon to see older people (people with established careers and families) that fall in love with this band. Because the lyrics are honest, they attract a wide range of listeners; the band is able to relate to a large range of listeners, because people relate to honesty. And so, while they are still signed to a major record label that ensures their music gets a wide release and wide advertising, there hasn’t been a change in that core honesty in their lyrics between being the unsigned indie band from the Twin Cities at their start, and now, the world touring band with roots in the Midwest.

-Lauren Ihrke

Monday, December 10, 2012

Creative Like Nicki Minaj (Yes, that is an Eponym)


The Music Video for "Your Love" can be found HERE. Click HERE for the lyrics to the song. 

Love her or hate her, Nicki Minaj and her popularity are at an all-time high. She has worked with artists like Madonna, Eminem, Bon Iver, Christina Aguilera, Drake, and even Justin Bieber. She can be seen- and her songs can be heard- in ads for Pepsi, Casio, and Nokia. Nicki will be making her debut as a judge on American Idol in 2013. Her popularity may seem questionable to some, but her appeal to certain audiences is undeniable. Nicki’s audience is a young, “hip”, more urban listener. Nicki is branding herself to this group not only in her image and music style, but also within the lyrics of her songs. She uses creative style to play to her target audience and increase her legitimacy as a hip-hop artist. She utilizes the rhetorical elements of Eponymn, Allusion, and Antisthecon to specifically appeal to certain groups and listeners.
            Nicki’s hit “Your Love” was released in June of 2010 and was on the Billboard top 100 songs chart and the Hot R&B/Hip Hop Songs Chart in the United States. She wrote the song with the help of writers Joseph Hughes, David Freedman, and Andrew "Pop" Wansel
. The song has classic Nicki hip-hop style with pop elements- appealing to her target audience.
            The first notable element of “Your Love”, and many Nicki Minaj songs, is that she uses Eponyms (using a person's name to refer to something they are known for). Often Eponyms are used so that most people would understand who is being talked about (i.e. “He is a real Einstein). Nicki, however, uses this creative device to reference people famous in pop-culture and hip-hop. This is taken to such an extent that the meaning of her song may be lost to those who are not up-to-date on these references. In the refrain of “Your Love” she uses the phrase, “For your lovin’ I would Die Hard like Bruce Willis.” If one does not know who Bruce Willis is (actor) and that he was in the movie series ‘Die Hard’ this phrase would not have meaning. Using an Eponym like this in the refrain is risky, because the listener may not understand a large portion of the song. She uses Eponym again when stating ‘I’m the one like I’m Tracy McGrady.’ Tracy McGrady is a basketball player whose number was ‘1’ for a large part of his career. If a reader does not know who McGrady is, let alone this information about his number, the pun Nicki is making would be rendered meaningless. Using such specific references to people in the song may seem like a questionable decision on the part of Minaj, but she trusts her audience not only knows what she is expressing but will also find the humor in the reference as a draw to the song.

Nicki Minaj uses another creative technique, Allusion (making a passing reference to a known person, object or event) similarly to how she used Eponym. The phrase ‘S on my Chest’ is used twice in “Your Love”. Here she is insinuating that she is like Superman, who famously wears the S on his chest. This reference may be understood by more listeners given Superman’s history in comics, television, and movies for a considerable period of time, while still being incredibly relevant to her normal audience. Allusion, as opposed to Eponym, allows Minaj to make references to pop-culture and the hip-hop/urban world outside of just people. The lyric “just left Moneygram in the Lemon Lam” may sound like a foreign language to many Americans because she is making two very hip-hop/urban driven references. Moneygram is a money transferring company and “Lemon Lam” is slang for a yellow Lamborghini. One may wonder why Nicki and the other writers of this song included a reference that would likely be lost on most listeners. The street terminology only helps build Nicki’s hip-hop image if heard, but the line takes place in a fast section and rhymes, so listeners less knowledgeable in this terminology may not notice or be bothered by the mystery Eponym. Urban listeners may understand her reference, “The Ave” which is referring to New York City. If one does not understand this nickname they may just think of “The Ave” as an alternate name for ‘the street.’ Her use of Allusion in the verses may confuse some fans, but her placement of them in the faster sections allow for her creativity to be appreciated by her target audience while still appealing to a wider fan base.
            Another major creative device Nicki Minaj utilizes in “Your Love” is antisthecon (changing the sound of a word). Often times songwriters use this technique to create rhyming patterns that make sense (changing ‘love’ to ‘lurve’ so it could rhyme with ‘serve’ or ‘nerve’). This song, however, uses antisthecon for a different purpose; the word’s sounds are changed to more sound like the way that people actually talk. Several times, instead of using ‘because’, she uses ‘cuz’. ‘Cuz’ is a syllable less than ‘because’ but this extra syllable is not the reason she changed the sound of the word. ‘Cuz’ is an extremely common shorthand used by younger people in America. The use of this word makes the song seem more conversational, like it is written for a group specifically and the way they talk. Another way she uses antisthecon is by taking the ‘g’ off of certain words like “loving” and “wanting”- turning them into “lovin” and “wantin”- another common mispronunciation among young people. The phrase, “Where tha certificate that I change my name on?” is a great example of this. She applies the antisthecon to the word “the.” If we were to write this in proper English most people would say, “Where is the certificate...” Nicki and the editors of her song were well aware of this, but chose not to change it. This is because ‘tha’ more accurately captures the way the fans they are trying to target would speak, or at least be a form of speech they are familiar with.   
            Nicki Minaj’s creative style uses rhetorical devices to appeal to her target audience, only increasing her popularity among them. While many can appreciate her rhymes and beats, only those she is truly trying to relate to will grasp the full meaning and influence of her songs. 
By: Emily Scheife

Paul Simon is Not Really a Rock


Simon and Garfunkel

If you look at them now, they don’t seem like much; old, wrinkled and scrunched-looking are some accurate descriptions.  But if you listen instead of look, it becomes apparent that Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel are still about as fresh as they were when their folk duo first formed.  Ever since the 1950’s when they recorded their first album as “Tom and Jerry,” their careers have both skyrocketed, their music became famous and their relationship has been through some tough strains. 

Although “The Sound of Silence,” “Mrs. Robinson” and “Bridge over Troubled Water” are by far their most popular and celebrated hits, I redirect you towards a forgotten and underrated gem written and performed by Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel in 1965 called “I am a Rock.”  This song is a masterpiece in both musical and literary worlds.  It was written after the popularity blast that was “The Sound of Silence” in 1964, and when compared, an argument could easily be made that “I am a Rock” is a continuation of “The Sound of Silence,” as the same solemn themes seem to permeate both pieces.  Simon introduces this song generally as a song about loneliness, but a closer look at the lyrics puts a colorful spin on the merits of solitude.  Numerous literary devices can be found throughout the lines and stanzas, many overlapping each other in a mess of poetic genius. Even though “I am a Rock” is about a speaker trying to convince the world that he is unaffected by the heartache of an excruciating love affair, it seems that Paul Simon is using the creative style more to try and convince himself of this unsure image of impenetrability.

“I am a Rock” kicks off with three consecutive splashes of alliteration.  These repetitions establish a gloomy setting in “a deep and dark December” and “on a freshly fallen silent shroud of snow.”  This device is effective in the sense that it links two or three separate images or feelings to conjure up specific combinations of phantasmagoria.  Also, it spices up what would otherwise be a boring couple of lines; there’s not a lot of action going on here because the function of this entire stanza is to lay a scene.  Simon does not use alliteration again after its rapid-fire succession in the introduction. 
Amplification is also utilized in the beginning and ending of the song.  He previously states that “I’ve built walls” but then goes on to continue that idea, comparing those previously built walls to “a fortress deep and mighty.”  When using this device, Paul Simon restates the idea of love and proceeds to build upon it in stanza two.  Metonymy is also used when he references his hardened resolve as “armor.” 

The epitome of creative analogies is the transferred epithet, which uses an entirely unrelated word that would not typically be used to describe an idea or concept.  For instance in stanza one, Simon uses the word “shroud” to describe snow.  This is odd because a shroud is a piece of clothing, and usually would never be used to describe any weather-related phenomena.  I’ve last seen it used mostly in regards to funeral shrouds, such as in The Odyssey, which would add another dark undertone to an already depressing song.  Stanza four modifies another noun with words that would not ordinarily describe it, saying “hiding in my room, safe within my womb.”  If this analogy was taken literally, the listener could deduce that Paul Simon possibly found an actual womb to seclude himself within, which is gross imagery.  However, we’re smart enough to know that he’s just using creative style to take the protective nature of a mother’s womb and transfer that same idea to his secluded room. 

The listener gets the general sense that this song is a conversation between Paul Simon and a nameless individual.  Procatalepsis is when the speaker anticipates an objection from some unknown person and responds to it.  This device is used one time in particular when Simon suddenly exclaims “Don’t talk of love.”  We don’t actually know who he’s talking to, but the entire song is almost like an intimate conversation focused on the trials and hard-learned lessons of one nasty love affair.  He is obviously trying to teach that nameless, faceless person to not make the mistakes he did, but as the song continues, it appears that the speaker is inwardly reflecting to himself.  His use of pronouns is indicative as such, and thus the song turns into one man’s attempt to convince himself that he is unaffected by emotional trauma.

If there is one sure way to convince one’s self of anything, it is through repetition.  Constantly Paul Simon restates that he is a rock and an island, always at the end of his stanzas.  This literary device is known as epistrophe, where words are repeated at the end of phrases.  “I am a rock, I am an island” is also an example of the song’s most prominent metaphors.  Generally this song is dripping with them.  In fact, the entire poem is an extended metaphor ornamented with smaller metaphors; so many levels of consciousness went into writing this stubbornly resolved song.  Hand in hand with those metaphors is personification.  It’s everywhere.  The more prominent places are:
  • ·         Stanza 3:  “Don’t talk of love… it’s sleeping in my memory.”
  • ·         Stanza 3: “I won’t disturb the slumber of feelings that have died.”
  • ·         Stanza 4: “I have my books and poetry to protect me.”
  • ·         Final Couplet: “And a rock feels no pain, and an island never cries.”

Personification runs rampant.  Love does not literally sleep, feelings cannot slumber, nor can they die.  If books and poetry had actual protective qualities, I’m sure they would be more of a novelty to today’s youth.  The concluding couplet states that rocks and islands don’t feel pain nor do they cry, which doesn’t seem like personification.  But really, it is; Paul Simon is still attributing human capabilities to those inanimate objects.  We are to assume that the rock cannot feel pain, but it can experience other emotions and sensations.  The island doesn’t cry, but it implies that it is capable of other emotions. 

All in all, this song is pretty low-key for such an emotionally turbulent theme.  The word selection Paul Simon uses creates an overall soft quality to the song that is enhanced by the soft style of Simon and Garfunkel’s unique sound.  Strong imagery is present throughout; it makes an already relatable song even more so and articulates the isolation and frozen status of Paul Simon’s personal life.  “I am a Rock” was written after Simon and Garfunkel firmly established themselves as musicians.  Its overall function is entertainment and art for art’s sake, but on an imaginative and universal level of understanding.  Extensive research returned inconclusive in regards to what or who this song was written for.  Simon and Garfunkel refuse to explain much of their music due to the intensely personal nature in which it was written, and this song is no exception.  One can postulate that it was written for therapeutic reasons, but other than that there’s no further explanation as to how it came to be.  

by Shelby Phillips


As Plain as Peanut Butter and Pickles


           The New York Times, one of the most widely read newspapers in the United States, has an extensive variety of readers, but if you had to characterize the average reader, what kind of person would it be? According to The Times’ own advertising kit, its average reader is 51 years old with a household income of close to $100,000.  The advertising kit goes on to say that 60% of its readers have at least a college level education, if not more schooling. In order to entertain their millions of readers, The Times has to publish a variety of interesting material, from current news, to sports, to culture and fashion.  While browsing the trending articles on the website, I saw that one was titled “Peanut Butter Takes On an Unlikely Best Friend”.  Being a fan of peanut butter, I clicked on the link to take a look at the article.  I read about how the author, Dwight Garner, enjoys eating peanut butter and pickle sandwiches and wonders why this particular sandwich isn’t more popular.  Once I finished the piece, I noticed something interesting.  Superficially, the article seems to fit into its surroundings in the Dining and Wine Section of The Times, but after further consideration, this article is somewhat out of place.

            At a glance, the text seems like any other article found in the section.  It is a piece about food among restaurant reviews, recipe suggestions, and other topics commonly found in the Dining and Wine section.  The piece is also stylistically similar to other articles found here.  The article is written in the plain style, as evidenced by the use of simple sentences, an average grade level of 8.2, and a reading ease of 67.1. The author uses this plain style interspersed with larger, more complex words to make the article accessible to readers while still sounding credible.  Evidence of this can be seen in this excerpt:
“I’ve been happily eating these distinctive little sandwiches for years. The vinegary snap of chilled pickle cuts, like a dash of irony, against the stoic unctuousness of peanut butter. The sandwich is a thrifty and unacknowledged American classic.”
On the surface, this all seems well and good.  An article about food belongs in the Dining and Wine section right? Even though what is on the surface appears to fit, let’s take a step back and look at the bigger picture.

            In the Dining and Wine section of the New York Times, you normally see articles about which grapes make the best wines, healthy recipes, and what dishes go best with persimmons.  So why is there an article about peanut butter and pickle sandwiches?  One possibility is that the author is purposely trying to be different.  He might be writing about an unusual food item in order to bring some novelty to the section, rather than writing another piece that only caters to those who are looking for fine dining suggestions.  An article about peanut butter adds a touch of simplicity to a place dominated by things like sparkling wines, risotto, and crown roast of pork.  The simplicity of the peanut butter and pickle sandwich is indeed a stark contrast to the normal cuisine featured in the Dining and Wine section, causing the article to stand out among the other stories.

            There is also contrast in genre between this article and those that surround it.  The usual articles are things like restaurant critiques, recipes, and wine advice.  Examples of these types of articles can be found here, here, and here. Garner’s piece, however, is almost like an ode to the peanut butter and pickle sandwich.  Whereas the other types of articles are meant to inform the reader about their respective topics, Garner celebrates his experiences with the sandwich over his lifetime and wants to spread his quirky snack food to anyone that will listen.  His zeal for the quirky food from his youth even went so far as to evoke responses from his readers about their love for the sandwich and other odd peanut butter combinations.  You can read the follow up article here. His ode ended up engaging his readers, which goes beyond those articles that are purely informative and adds another layer of complexity to the text.  This different genre choice makes Garner’s article seem like it doesn’t fit in the context of this section.

            Despite the fact that this article seems to be appropriate at first glance, Garner’s tribute to the peanut butter and pickle sandwich isn’t suited for the Dining and Wine section after comparing it to other articles found in the same area.  So how did this get past the editors if it doesn’t follow the conventions usually found in the section?  Perhaps being different is rewarded in some sections of The Times.  As opposed to the straight reporting of facts in the news, some areas might take on a more creative approach in order to entertain readers.  This balance between creative and plain styles might be a common occurrence in journalism, but that is an investigation for another time.  Whatever the case, Garner’s article about peanut butter and pickles certainly entertained me and many other readers, making his article a very successful one, no matter what section of the New York Times it ended up in.

You can read Garner’s article in full here.


---John E Yeakel

Bias and Satire: Preschool Nothing



As soon as my Time Magazine comes each week, I flip it over, turn to the second to last page and read Joel Stein’s Awesome Column. During busy weeks when I can’t find time to read the rest of the periodical, this is the only part of the magazine I read—and my subscription is still completely worth it. Laced with sarcasm and a biting, intelligent sense of humor, this is always worth the time. Over the years, I've acquired the widest array of useless knowledge through Stein’s writing—soaking up everything from Stein’s attempt for someone to call him (maybe) to his wife’s experience with placenta pills. And though it may seem out of place within the context of a news periodical, the activity system surrounding its publication as well as it genre allow the Awesome Column to fit right in. In this particular article, biting satire challenges the actions of wealthy people—it certainly has bias against their decisions, but, presented as satirical, is acceptable.

This entire article is about trying to get Stein’s son into an Ivy-League equivalent preschool. Stein, as a well-known author, has the money to get him there, but he does not have the old-money social standing. The article contains bias against the very rich, poking fun at the people who can actually afford (and have the name) to send their preschoolers to class at the cost most of us pay for college. The reason Stein gets away with this is because of activity systems—the readers are expecting his style—and also through the use of satire as a device to mock old-money social norms. The use of satire not only makes Stein’s article entertaining  but it is a socially acceptable (and funny) way to critique other people’s decisions.

This piece is accepted because this is the writing that readers of Time have come to accept on the second to last page—it is part of the Time Magazine activity system. The subjects of the system are Time’s readers. An important thing to note about Time’s readership is that it’s very limited. I don’t mean this in the sense that people don’t read it, many do—and it will soon be the only weekly print news periodical in the United States. By limited, I mean that Time does a relatively thorough job of regulating its audience. Parts of the magazines can be read without a subscription, but most cannot. The Awesome Column specifically cannot be viewed without a digital or print subscription. This partly occurs because of conflicting motives within the activity system. Though the subjects, the readers, consume the periodical for information and entertainment, other communities don’t have the same goal. Time, as a company, for example, exists to turn a profit. In order to do this, they cannot give much content away for free—thus, the limit their subject group. By doing this, the activity system is tightened. Its players have a better idea of what goes on within it and there isn't as much worry about how it may be consumed by someone outside the activity system. An example of the purified activity system is through its norms. One of the magazine’s norms is its format, which it doesn't waiver from each week. This isn't just the design, but expands further to content as well. Certain columnists write weekly. Additionally, there is always a cover story. The magazine also has several pages that aren't stories—for example, it features the week in quotations. The Awesome Column, where this was printed, is at the second to last page of each publication. Readers, subjects, know what to expect when they skim through the magazine.

This is why information that seems so trivial—a story about an author’s sun not getting accepted to preschool fits in. Readers expect Stein’s column to not be headline news. Additionally, readers are expecting entertainment. Under this guise, satire, which is a genre of entertainment writing, can be used to make social comments. Though some readers might not understand the underlying class bias in this article, that’s the point. The article on the surface exists purely for entertainment. This is why the article even serves a function outside its original activity system. If a reader picks up the magazine who hasn't read it before, the Awesome Column is placed right where they may flip—the second to last page. And though it is sarcastic and snappy, it provides the perfect hook for a reader who may be otherwise disengaged by the traditional news—a reader who probably wouldn't hold a Time subscription. The article exists first for entertainment, but is also utilized as social commentary. This story is funny because its ridiculous. It is funny because most people would never ever consider putting their children in a preschool that costs more than some pay in college tuition. So the satire proves a point—that this whole operation is a little bit loony. This is all made possible through rhetorical devices which contribute to its satire. Below, I have outlined the devices I see as most important in this process.

Hyperbole is a device where the author uses exaggeration to prove a point. A few of Stein’s examples are:

           “I'm pretty sure he will now never listen to any advice I give him for the rest of his life.”

           “kids decide what project to do, which is yelling”

            “I was pretty sure we were going to be the first parents to end the preschool application process
            with a prison term.”

Through the use of hyperbole, Stein is able to “stretch” each phrase by amplifying its meaning or importance. His son will eventually listen to him, children make choices in ways other than yelling, and he is not going to end up in prison. Yet, by blurring the line between what actually happened, taking the action just a step further, Stein begins to prove that each of these things are foolish. This contributes to the work’s satire as it makes things funny, calling attention to them that wouldn’t be.

Like hyperbole exaggerates meaning, periphrasis literally overuses the number of words needed to form a message. It draws attention to something that would not receive as much without an overwhelming number of words, exaggerating the importance of an event when it could easily be more understated:

                “Laszlo met his trouble with great magnanimity.”

It’s odd to use the word “magnanimity” to describe a four year old. It is even odder to describe a four year old who hasn’t been accepted to a prestigious preschool but has no idea. Stein could have simply said that Lazlo wasn’t disappointed by his not getting into preschool, but he didn’t. In doing so we, as readers, are forced to see how silly it is that a very young child would be put in such an odd situation.

In addition to exaggerating words and meaning, satire also works because of its close ties to pop culture. Allusion is a device used to call on images that the reader would already understand, engaging the reader in things he or she would find familiar:

“I will offer 10-to-1 odds that Michele Bachmann uses poopy and pee-pee and that Ron Paul uses bowel movement and urination.”

“It's like a bad teen movie where I'd get the popular girl to take me into her clique and then tell her, 'I don't want to be in your clique.’”

“I spent Saturdays sitting on a tiny chair trying to look involved and shaking a tambourine and dancing around in a circle while Laszlo refused to move, staring at me with utter disrespect.”

Allusion works in satire because it provides connection to the reader’s world. If satire is too far into the clouds, readers cannot understand how it relates to their lives, and therefore, satire does not have its intended ridiculous effect. In these examples, Stein draw’s on a cultural knowledge and cultural connection to Michelle Bachmann, Ron Paul, bad teen movies, and entertaining young children. Additionally, we see in the first example a reference to very important, wealthy people, contributing to bias against the very wealthy.
Another way to mock a situation is through the use of diazeugma where one word is tied to multiple, unrelated words, creating humor in their contradictions. Stein is discussing questions on preschool applications, and the one question he though was most brilliant:

The brilliant one was "What's your word use for bowel movement and urination?" This should be asked at every job interview, first date and presidential debate.

Diazeugma takes the word “this” (which refers to the “brilliant question”) and applies it to “job interview,” “first date,” and “presidential debate.” Not only does this save word space—without the use of diazeugma, we would probably have three separate sentences to describe same idea—but it also compares three very different things because they all share one word. By doing so, we see how seemingly strange this question really is—applied to any of the mentioned circumstances (aside from a preschool application); it is a very odd question to answer. Showing how strange this question is by using the rhetorical device diazeugma contributes to the overall satirical narrative because it brings to light how abnormal it is to ask that question in any context.  

We also see a general use of comedy throughout this text. And though this is not a literary device, I believe part of comedy is being able to jokingly reference a previous part of the conversation. Satire works because it is biting, but also because it is funny. The comic work also jokes within itself, alluding to what Stein references previously:

            “One week earlier, Cassandra's grandmother, with whom she was very close, had died. She did not cry.”

Followed by:

“Cassandra cried the cry of a woman who has lost eight grandmothers.”

By referencing jokes within the text, Stein keeps up a tone he has already created.

Finally, in a championed use of the creative style, Stein pokes fun at the official style’s use of ambiguous terminology to describe everyday objects. The official style is politically correct and professional, just like the “old money” people Stein mocks. By writing in the official style, he portrays their lives as more elite than everyone else’s: their kids don’t play with blocks, they play with pedagogical tools.

The school administrators were clearly nervous about charging $15,000 a year for these programs, because they all described blocks as "pedagogical tools."

Stein takes play, something totally unofficial, and elevates it in status. In the same way, he makes fun of people who “officialize” childhood, elevating its status.  

We see the value of the article beyond just its words. Rhetorical devices create satire. Satire sets a tone. That tone mocks and jokes about very wealthy people—and the narrative mocks a situation that only very wealthy people find themselves in. Yet, the satire makes this article funny and entertaining, so it functions within its activity system even when readers don’t see its underlying social commentary.

By Karin Johnson

Eggs, Plain Style Please


The Op-Ed piece being discussed can be found HERE
“Is an Egg for Breakfast Worth This?” is an opinion piece written by New York Times Opinion writer Nicholas D. Kristof. He writes about farming practices concerning egg-laying hens, specifically those that were under secret investigation at Kreider Farms. The New York Times has quite a broad readership and Kristof writes to appeal to the masses, while still managing to fit in facts and his own opinion. He utilizes a plain style of writing to his advantage to not only convey his message to the American people but also to persuade them to his line of thinking.
            The first thing a reader may notice, even before reading the piece, is the way that the article is organized. The piece is broken up into nineteen small paragraphs, ranging in size from four sentences to one sentence in a paragraph. These small paragraphs allow him to keep information brief and concise. He is not bombarding the reader with massive amounts of information and detail, but instead making his point and moving on. Many of his paragraphs begin with coordinators or transitions statements: “In some cases...”, “But...” “Like many readers...”, “Granted...”, “Somehow...” These statements keep the flow of the essay while connecting many ideas. Although simple and concise sentences are an important element of the plain style, and are crucial for the understanding of the general public, readers should be wary of oversimplifications that Kristof is making by keeping the paragraphs so short and simple.
            Kristof builds a way into his piece to cover himself on oversimplification. Although he avoids much technical jargon (Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations (CAFOs) is the technical term for ‘factory farm’) and goes on to define or elaborate on any definitions or groups that may not be common knowledge- a rhetorical technique known as distincto- he also built in quick-links to lesser-known topics. When he brings up an organization, like the Humane Society of the United States, a reader can simply click on the phrase and be transported to the Humane Society’s website. This way a reader can easily go on to make his or herself more informed, without Kristof having to get overly technical. This is a brilliant way to use the plain style. He keeps the average reader interested but allows the reader who desires more detailed information access to it easily.
            Although this is an opinion piece, an important part of Kristof’s persuasion technique involves his credibility. Part of this credibility is achieved by showing the perspectives of both the undercover investigator and the president of Kreider Farms. Kristof parallels his treatment of quoting the investigator by also directly quoting the Kreider Farm’s president. Kristof continues to maintain authority by stating specific facts and numbers: Kreider Farms ‘produces 4.5 million eggs each day for supermarkets’ and that Salmonella turns up ‘in 3 percent of egg factory farms tested by the Food and Drug Administration last year.’ Readers are going to be more trusting of an author that is willing to show both sides and give hard facts, especially facts from trustworthy government sources.
            The voice that Kristof writes in appears conversational and he does not steer away from using first and second person. This is not only an important element of plain style writing, it also is what makes this a good, and persuasive, opinion piece. Readers feel comfortable; they are being told in a relateable and simplistic terms about the egg-farming situation- a situation they may not know much about. He gives specific and concrete examples, a strategy called exemplum, to make his points solid. He describes the exact conditions the chickens are experiencing and even gives specifics as to how many were jammed in a cage: “In some cases, 11 hens were jammed into a cage about 2 feet by 2 feet.” Once he has the horrors of the situation described, he uses his own thoughts and feelings followed by exemplum to persuade the reader that it is natural to feel the way he does. “Still, I flinch at a system in which hens are reduced to widgets. Many of us do, which is why Burger King, Denny’s, Quiznos and Hardee’s have started buying more free range eggs.” Here, the fast food restaurants are serving as a concrete example of how many people feel about the conditions of egg-laying hens. His personal stories, although captivating to the reader, should send an alarm to readers about Kristof’s bias.
            Kristof created an informative, authoritative, and yet relateable and persuasive opinion piece by using the elements of the plain style. Readers should be wary of oversimplification and bias that may exist, but overall can trust the author and the source. 
By: Emily Scheife

The Fast Lane to Comprehension


          As we think about the modern American society, we usually imagine a fast-paced society with little time for entertainment.  Where we once sat at the dinner table with a newspaper and morning coffee, now we spend perhaps five to ten minutes glancing at a computer or smartphone.  Obviously, these small windows of time no longer allow us to explore page-long articles; we need short blurbs that provide interest and information in just a few short paragraphs.  Yet, this compression of space and time comes at a cost.  In the article “Tsunami bike at Harley-Davidson Museum” by Rick Barrett, we can evaluate the costs and benefits this new style brings to journalism.


            First, we immediately notice the article’s brevity.  On the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel website, Barrett’s entry takes up roughly a fourth of the page’s length.  Mind you, this is also with extra spacing between the paragraphs to increase readability, so the actual length is even smaller than what we see.  It’s not hard to understand how a reader could glance through this in five minutes and know what this article is saying.  However, brevity comes with a price.  By cutting down, Barrett ends up with one sentence paragraphs: “The container had Japanese writing on it, and the bike's license plate indicated it was from Japan.”  Where he could have gone into a great depth about the recovery and add levels of emotion, he leaves the reader with the most basic understanding of the experience.  In fact, the article is only eleven sentences long, with only two paragraphs being longer than one sentence.  Rather than build a personal investment with the experience, Barrett chooses to lay it out as a matter of fact.


            Next, we mark Barrett’s word choice.  Rather than bog the reader down with long, flowered sentences, the writer has chosen to remain on the layman’s level, so to speak.  In fact, sometimes he intentionally makes redundant statements to clarify his sentence’s intentions: “the container had Japanese writing on it, and the bike's license plate indicated it was from Japan.”  I use this example again because it demonstrates the motives behind plain style writing!  Barrett could have gone with either idea -the container or the license plate- and most readers would reach the same conclusion after some initial thinking.  Instead, he removes all the reader’s hassle with a touch of epistrophe.


            Essentially, the crux plain writing is to establish an idea in a way that is understood without much (if any) second guessing.  While this desire leads to some habits that make scholars and professional writers cringe, such as redundancy or simplicity, audiences as a whole have embraced this style.  This is probably why we see it being used so prevalently in free-form communications like blogs, newspapers and other multimedia outlets.
By Matthew Otto

Research or Restate? An “Official” Look at a Research Results Article


Research or Restate? An “Official” Look at a Research Results Article


                In light of the recent Jennifer Livingston fiasco I found an article related to bullying. It is titled “Bullying and Suicide: Detection and Prevention”. Though I found it online, it was originally published in 2011 in a journal called The Psychiatric Times. After a little research I found they have an extensive member’s only website in addition to the journal. In 2011 bullying was taking center stage in the media after the suicides of many teens as a result of bullying and the introduction of cyber-bullying. The breadth of cyber-bullying was beginning to be more fully understood as more and more reports flooded in. As Jennifer Livingston and the article pointed out, “bullying has become a major public health problem in the Western world” (Klomek et al., 2011). However, the article being written at a grade level of 15.0 was not meant for the general population to read.

                Since the article was written for a journal called The Psychiatric Times it is easy to speculate that its readership is fairly narrow. The main audience would be doctors, psychologists, psychiatrists, and other health care professionals. With the access to the internet some schools or parents may also want to read it. The article was authored by Anat Brunstein Klomek, PhD, Andre Sourander, MD and Madelyn S. Gould, PhD, MPH. In all consideration that it is a report done on a study, I assumed its reading level would be higher than 15.0. However, the authors kept the jargon light and kept the article mainly to the results of the study, rather than elaborating on causes. With this being said the information was very redundant. This six page article could have been summed up in a much shorter frame. Granted, that is official style for you. The sentence structure was very repetitive as well. This is among one of many reasons I felt that the official style was not all that effective in this piece.

                “The association between bullying behavior at age 8 years and later suicide attempts and completed suicides varied by sex. Among boys, bullying behavior at age 8 years was not associated with later suicide attempts and completed suicides, after controlling for both childhood conduct and depression symptoms. Frequent victimization among girls at age 8 years, however, was associated with later suicide attempts and completed suicides, even after controlling for childhood conduct and depression symptoms. These findings indicate that suicidal behavior among boys who frequently bully others may be a function of psychopathology rather than of the bullying behavior per se.”

                The most monotonous part of the article was the word choice. While I understand that the authors stayed true to the topic of the paper, the sentences offered very little variety. Even in the paragraph above the words bullying and suicide were used eleven times. While in the true nature of official style the sentences are long winded, they lack a verbose quality that makes them a bad combination of lengthy and dull. The sentence structure was varied at times, but overall not enough to keep things interesting. The article’s readability score came to 28.8 with a SMOG index of 12.5. These statistics are not overwhelmingly high, but the characters per word came back at 5.6 which are higher than I would have expected. The words per sentence averaged out to be 18.8; a bit short for official style, but longer than the average Joe sentence. Overall, it seems that the authors are attempting to be plain in their speech, but still writing in a way that is partially into official style. With the article being scientific in nature the authors would have been better off writing more plainly. The other option would have been to make the piece more official style. Either option would have been fine as long as they stuck to one specific type of writing rather than this in between area.

                With the writing as is, the article functions only partially within the assumed activity system. Given the presumed audience of the article, the authors failed to write in a way that would best benefit their readers. The authors wrote that they had written previous work on the topic. While this may add to their credibility it made me wonder why they were writing the article in the first place. The most likely answers would be that they wanted to inform the public or their colleagues about their research and findings, that they wanted to raise awareness about this particular problem, or that they were asked to do a write up on their research. However, I had to wonder if they were only writing the article to benefit themselves. By putting out more current research or by simply writing another article they would get more recognition in their field. What led me to believe this is the fact that the article had little new information throughout it and it cited many other similar studies on the same topic. Why bother writing an article that has little novel findings and merely regurgitates other studies? While it is not stated outright in the article, it could be an underlying drive. Also, the article does not fit the norm for scientific articles. Normally, articles such as this are much more in depth, filled with scientific jargon, and include much more detail and statistics. The piece did not measure up the norm. The authors were describing the results of an experiment they did, while failing to explain the procedure. The readers would have no clue as to how things were measured, over what time period, and the general demographics of the group being studied. This conflicts with the layout of most all scientific articles.

                With their implied audience being generally that of highly educated medical professionals they do not use the type of language I would normally expect. The lack of jargon makes this piece not fit within its given activity system. Without technical jargon the piece does not speak to its audience on a level that would be the most helpful for them. By failing to use appropriate jargon the article is not detailed enough to give the readers the information they really need. In addition to jargon they lack any real data to support their claims. Their claims that any type of suicidal ideation or depression has increased due to any type of bullying is not backed up by actual data. They do not indicate any numbers, statistics, or other information to back up their claims. Considering it is a paper written to state their research findings they do not live up to the norms of a research paper.

                All of this completely violates the activity system the document should be functioning in. The article is not functioning as a normal scientific paper should. It does not serve its audience as it should. The paper does not serve its community as it should since it does not actually give any information valuable to its readers. The intentions of the paper were not fulfilled unless the authors planned to just write something to publish an article for attention or to further their professional careers. Even the title of the article is not particularly true to the content. The title of Bullying and Suicide: Detention and Prevention. There is no real information on detection or prevention of bullying or suicide. The title is misleading to readers who want that type of information since there is not really any information on detection or prevention.       

                Overall, while the article used the official style it did not use it in an effective way. The lack of jargon and real information makes this piece not function as it is intended to. The repetitive nature of the word choice and sentences made the article boring and much longer than necessary. If they had any information that could validate their claims it would have made the article more valuable and credible. The authors should really think about what they are going to write before they write a report just for kicks.