Monday, October 14, 2013

“The Doll House Backlash: Criticism, Feminism and Ibsen”: Establishing Credibility, Alienating Readers



Published by the Modern Language Association in their journal PMLA, “The Doll House Backlash: Criticism, Feminism and Ibsen” presents the argument that Ibsen never meant for A Doll House to be about women’s rights and so it isn’t. The author’s purpose of this article is to present an alternate idea of the intended purpose of the play. To establish credibility, she uses multiple elements of the official style which results in the alienation of the reader.
According to the Modern Language Association, PMLA is distributed to “about 28,000 college and university teachers of English and foreign languages who belong to the association and to about 1,900 libraries throughout the world” (Modern Language Association). The journal is aimed at “scholars and teacher of language and literature” (Modern Language Association). Those in the fields of language and literature are the target audience of the journal, though as it is distributed to many libraries, scholars in several other fields would have access to it.
For this particular piece, those interested in women’s studies, theater studies, and literary studies would be interested because of the connection both the play and playwright have in the history of women’s rights. Because it is distributed directly to professors of language as well as to libraries, those who may see it range from student to expert. Experts in language may take interest in the article for a perspective they had not previously considered or for a new way to look at a text or to show students new ways to view a text. Experts in women’s studies may take interest in the article because it refutes a widely-held idea of A Doll House as a play about women’s rights. Experts in theatre studies may read the article to gain insight for creating their own production of the play. Because of the section in on tautology, experts in philosophy may be interested in this article as an example of how logic is used in literature. Students of these fields may find the article for these same reasons, but also as part of research to learn what others are saying and using those ideas to make their own contributions. Personally, I discovered this text when in the process of writing my own paper about the ideas in A Doll House as an undergrad student. Ultimately, I chose not to use the text because it was taking too long for me to get to the core of what the author was trying to say.
An excerpt from the first paragraph in the article received an average grade level of 18.4. Simply looking at this readability score, we can see the extent that the author alienates readers. Since the average American reads at about the 7th grade level, this article was obviously not designed for them. “Now, if this is so, the explanation can only be that the men, who already possess the rights women seek, are excluded from the female struggle, which is precisely, a struggle for equality with them (Templeton 31). One of many like it, this complex sentence only alienates the reader with all the modifiers: “Now, if this is so” are examples of sentenial adverb; “who already possess the rights women seek” is a relative clause; “which is, precisely” is a scesis onomaton (repetition of the same word/phrase to mean the same thing); “a struggle for equality with them” is an appositive. Complex sentences such as this add to the heightened readability grade level. Not only does it take a longer time to get to the point, the main idea is not as clear. 
 (Figure 1. Image of the original text)
The use of diction further alienates the reader. The author uses highly uncommon words and dropping other languages in when disputing an idea: “The a priori dismissal of women's rights as the subject of A Doll House is a gentlemanly backlash …the issue is decidedly vieux jeu, and its importance has been greatly exaggerated” (Templeton 29). Give me a minute while I go look up what both a priori and vieux jeu mean. Add on top of that her use of “tautology” –those without a background in philosophy or logic would not know what she was talking about. She does not take any time to explain what tautology is to a literary audience but has a two page section of her article, “The High Claims of Art and Tautology: “Beyond Feminism” to Men”, dedicated to its significance in relation to A Doll House (Templeton 31). Though she may be simply demonstrating her vast array of knowledge, readers of the PMLA are from all over the world. Because many of those who would come into contact with this article are assumed to be college educated, and likely in the literary field, the author feels comfortable using a variety of language. Colleges in America require a specific number of General Education credits so students receive a well-rounded education, allowing them access to knowledge from literary studies to logic. Unfortunately, the author assumes that all education systems are the same when they aren’t. Those studying English in London, for example, are going to have taken lessons strictly related to English. Not everyone in America will even have had a logic course. The word “tautology” is an introductory level logic course vocabulary word, but without the understanding of it, “The High Claims of Art and Tautology” is difficult to understand. The same follows for “priori” and “vieux jeu”.
The author’s use of euphemism when referencing other works of literature helps her build credibility with those readers with a literary background but at the same time alienates those without one. Though the article was published in a journal targeted towards those in literary studies and potentially those in feminist studies, the author makes the assumption that anyone reading her article would have an understanding of a wide range of literary references. She concludes one of her primary ideas in saying, “Thus, it turns out, the Uncle Tom's Cabin of the women's rights movement is not really about women at all” (Templeton 28). The author could just as easily have said “Ibsen’s A Doll House was not about women at all”. In this specific sentence, the author is not only referencing Uncle Tom’s Cabin in a way that only those who have studied it would understand, but she is also making use of it as a euphemism. “Ibsen’s A Doll House” becomes “the Uncle Tom’s Cabin of the women’s rights movement”.
The Official Style can be used to successfully establish credibility when used both sparingly and with clarity, something this article fails to do. When used extensively as with this article, it can alienate readers. The reader can see that the author is knowledgeable in multiple fields of study, increasing the author’s credibility. Despite this, the author draws on information from multiple fields of study, information known by a limited number of scholars. The use of the Official Style reinforces the elite circle of people able to understand and use a text. This is especially true with a text like this one which is relevant to those who have read A Doll House and wish to further analyze it. The amount of people who understand all aspects of the text is smaller than the number of people who read the article because the author draws an entire selection from the field of philosophy with the logical analysis (the section in which the author discusses the tautology of the play) when the journal is aimed at readers with a literary background, not a philosophy background. Similarly written texts face the same issues of alienation. Despite attempts to make the article relevant to multiple fields of study, the author alienates many people in the PMLA’s target audience who lack expertise in every field incorporated in the article.
~B.N.

Templeton, Joan. “The Doll House Backlash: Criticism, Feminism, and Ibsen”. PMLA. Vol 104 Issue 1 (1989). 28-40. JStore. Web. 27 September 2013.
“PMLA”. Modern Language Association, n.d. Web. 5 Oct. 2013.
 

Sunday, October 13, 2013

Analyzing the Art of Journalism

         
  When contemplating Eleanor Roosevelt, the first thoughts to appear in one’s mind most likely revolve around her involvement in American political history. Her husband, Franklin Delano Roosevelt, led the nation through the Great Depression and World War II, gaining recognition for public service program advocacy, while Eleanor performed her First Lady duties. What many are not aware of, however, is Eleanor’s competency as a skilled journalist in her time. “Recent Directions for the Study of Women’s History in American Journalism,” an article written by Maurine Beasley of the University of Maryland, seeks to bring awareness to the struggle and history of female American journalists, who have characteristically experienced adversity in the press world.
            This article, written at the seventeenth grade level, is laden with official style language. While much of the article includes long lists discussing the names and accomplishments of women journalists, it also brings in a methodical, scholarly perspective as it explores the influence of these women in media publication history. For example, one argument that Beasley expresses indicates women have not been given adequate recognition for their writing. Beasley probably encounters at least some level of support for this theory, considering that her article was published in a periodical called Journalism Studies. After some research, I discovered that Journalism Studies forms a branch of the Taylor & Francis Group, an international organization that distributes academic journals as well as books. It appears to send out physical copies of its journals, though the examples I found were online versions. The entirety of the Taylor & Francis association puts off a very educational, professional vibe, which is characteristic of academic journals. Thus, I concluded that Journalism Studies has a limited readership stemming from those interested in written communications.
            Reading this article gave me a slight feeling of inferiority, almost belittlement, which is ironic concerning its context. Beasley uses lofty language to solidify her authority over the reader, employing such examples as “pursued in various stages of conceptualization,” and “fit into the compensatory and contribution categories” (Beasley 210, 211)  almost in an effort to confuse her reader, or perhaps weed out those who would not be able to comprehend the text. Granted, Beasley has to be held to this standard as an academic writer. If she chose to write in a simple manner, her work probably would not be published in Journalism Studies. The complex level of writing Beasley engages in is not explicitly her choice, but rather one that society has established for academic writing. As a female journalist myself, I found it irritating to have to sift through Beasley’s flowery word choice and patronizing tone to simply get the “meat” out of the article. Several of her ideas were repeated with altered sentence structure or different words. Repetitive phrasing is characteristic of the official style, but one would imagine that a journalist writing about journalism would pick up on her own prose style more adeptly than someone who has not chosen a career that requires extensive writing.
            This sentence in particular stood out as I read through Beasley’s article: “These three approaches cover family-oriented studies that take in the personal as well as the professional, inquiry into journalistic networking along gender lines, and narratives that emphasize the emergence of women’s voices” (Beasley 208). The sentence following it reads: “In short, they call for looking at women in journalism through a wider lens than previously has been used” (Beasley 208). In the first sentence, several official style examples can be noticed. Beasley prevalently employs euphemism with such expressions as “journalistic networking” and “family-oriented studies.” She draws out sentences with complicated phrasing and verbosity that exasperates the reader. In fact, she even includes a second sentence to sum up the point of the first sentence, which appears almost comical to the reader. Beasley realizes that her manner of writing could confuse her audience, but instead of modifying the initial sentence to make more sense, she adds a second sentence to clear up her mucky vocabulary.
            On the Flesch-Kincaid Reading Ease scale, “Recent Directions” scored a smooth 25, indicating its complexity. It surprised me to learn that this article exercised an average of 29 words per sentence, as it seemed to utilize more elaborate words frequently in its lengthy sentences. Passivity cast a shadow over the whole of the article, directing verb style in an official mode. Several times, I caught myself having to re-read entire paragraphs, simply because they are written so stuffily. Below is another example of the euphemistic language and overly complex sentence structure conveyed throughout Beasley’s article, seeming to give an elevated edge to her manner of speech.

            “According to Lerner (1979), the compensatory stage represented the identification of women previously omitted from standard historical accounts. Moving beyond it, Lerner described the contribution stage as the evaluation of women’s achievements in a male-dominated world, the transition stage as the reworking of various historical categorizations from women’s perspectives, and the synthesis stage as the integration of the history of men and women’s experience” (Beasley, 210).

            Long lists in sentences such as the second one made it difficult for me to work my way through the article, though Beasley has accurately created an official piece for her activity system. If fellow journalists are going to be reading ”Recent Directions,” they will most likely be accustomed to formal language and having to work through extended sentence structure. Most of them will not experience the same exasperation I did as I was reading through Beasley’s article, since they probably write like her. The norm for her community is that writing must be official and professional. A journalist’s motive is to inform, and Beasley does accomplish her goal of doling out information to her audience. Maybe a more accurate motive for Beasley, given her activity system, is to establish a sense of credibility. Beasley knows that Journalism Studies expects her to write academically, and without using jargon typical of  the official style, she cannot accomplish this task. She could have easily kept her sentences short and plain, but that would not have served her readership in the way it must to maintain the academic standard.

            The plight of the female journalist seems to be an interesting topic, one that I find personally appealing and others may as well. However, Beasley’s ornate language and dramatically lengthy sentences took away from her message: women in journalism deserve more recognition. By choosing to take a superior stance over the reader and create a confusing effect throughout the article, Beasley enshrouded her true purpose for the piece and frustrated my efforts to understand her perspective fully. After reading this article, I am not so sure that Eleanor Roosevelt would feel proud to have paved the way for this type of journalism. Perhaps academic journalism as a whole needs to change its tune and broaden its appeal so the common person can understand the important issues discussed within the bindings of the official style. 

By D.M. Cook

Playing the Game


The current critique focuses on my analysis of an article entitled, “Micro Credit in Chiapas, Mexico: Poverty Reduction through Group Lending,” by Gustavo Barboza and Sandra Trejos. I believe that legal terminology and jargon, professional references, and complex, meticulous details are used by the authors in the context of this article to produce the effects of credibility and expertise.
Before getting into the details of my analysis the context must first be determined. The article was published in 2009, but uses data collected between July 2000 and July 2001. Published in the Journal of Business Ethics, Vol. 88, the article was part of a supplement focusing on Central America and Mexico.
Both authors are associated with the Clarion University of Pennsylvania, which is located in Clarion, Pennsylvania. According to Clarion’s website, the school was established in 1867, has about 6,500 students, and is one of the several public higher education institutions in Pennsylvania. While both researchers are from Clarion, they are in different departments, with Barboza in the Department of Administrative Science and Trejos in the Department of Economics.
Overall, the article is fairly easy to read, with Flesch-Kincaid Reading Scores ranging from 20 to 30 depending on the section. The average grade also varies but hovers around 16. The article focuses on Micro Crediting, which is a type of program designed to aid impoverished people by providing easier means of credit loaning. The reason why it is usually so difficult to give those who are poor credit is because they often have little to no collateral, or anything to exchange if they do not live up to their end of the deal and repay the loan. Since banks want insurance that they will be repaid in some way or another they will most likely refuse credit to anyone who is especially poor.
Micro crediting, or micro loaning, offers a creative and innovative solution. Different organizations have different methods, but generally speaking they will offer credit if a family or larger group agrees to hold the individual responsible. What this does is make the loanee responsible to several members of the community as well as the bank, and the community is there to help each other repay the loans. Without knowledge in this area micro lending can be a confusing subject, but the authors do not spend much time explaining it since the typical readers of this article would already know what it is.
The official style is used in a wide array of contexts, and for many different purposes, but for this specific article I believe that it was purposely used to establish a sense of credibility and expertise. The authors knew that their publication would be read by a select few: the economists and businesspeople of the world who are interested in Micro Credit programs. Therefore they needed to prove themselves as trustworthy, credible sources who knew what they were talking about. The authors did this by using legal terminology and jargon, citing professional and academic references, and by providing meticulous details about their research.
It is common in official style to use complex sentence structures along with jargonistic terminology. Barboza and Trejos did this exceptionally well, and it is easy to notice. Since the article focused on economic practices there is a lot of jargon related to economics and loaning procedures. Some examples are “liquidity,” “delinquency,” and “arrears.” Arrears is so specific to loaning that I had to look up the definition. It is a legal term for the part of a debt that is overdue after missing one or more required payments. These are examples of terms that are generally more common amongst economists and bankers. Because of the audience, the authors deliberately used jargon to establish their credibility and professionalism. By correctly and frequently using specific jargon of the field the authors sent a clear message that they are “in.” They know the terminology, they are part of the inner circle, and so they can be trusted to provide reliable information to other members of said in-group.
In addition to simply using jargon, the authors threw terms together in complex and almost non-understandable ways. This strategy is typical of the official style and provides an even further sense of expertise. Whether the readers can understand the sentence or not is irrelevant, because the authors clearly understand it since they wrote it, and since they understand such a complex sentence they must know what they are talking about. One of my favorite phrases from the article that serves as a perfect example of this is, “The relative convergence to lower delinquency.” It really rolls off the tongue.
Jargon, although frequently an annoying aspect of the official style, is somewhat necessary to get published in today’s academic journals. If jargon is not used, it is presumed that the author does not know the jargon. If the author does not know the jargon, then the author must not really be an expert. Never mind the fact that it makes the article unreadable to most of the world. Jargon makes the author look smart, and the smarter they look, the more likely they are to be published. The more published an author becomes, the smarter they look. I think we can see the cyclical issue here.
The references the authors cite also play a key role in developing a level of credibility. The logic follows that if the sources are credible and expert then the article referencing them likely is as well. It is the same strategy as using complex, jargonistic sentences: appearing to know a lot about the subject matter and a lot about other people who know a lot about the subject matter. The article cites many authors, books, and other articles, but of interest are the types of journals that have published cited works. The referenced journals include the Quarterly Journal of Economics, Journal of Development Economics, Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics, The American Economic Review, and the Journal of Economic Literature. Each of these sources sounds legitimate, which makes, “Micro Credit in Chiapas, Mexico,” seem more legitimate as well. The references also send a clear message about the intended audience of the article.
In academic writing it is imperative that one uses important and reputable references. The reference game is part of the larger picture of academic journals and the official style. Besides simply appearing to know more about the subject, the references chosen for an article are a key into the world of academia. If the right references are selected, you are in. If you choose wrongly, you are out. They key is to cite references that many other experts in the field are familiar with, so they know that you are legitimate. By citing references, a paper becomes part of a network. You cite article A, article B cites you, article C (written by the author of article A) cites article B. Suddenly you are in simply by choosing the right references. It is a game. Not only a game to come off as professional and expert, but also to get published and included in the circle of the “knows” instead of the “know-nots.”
A third strategy often employed by the official style, and used by Barboza and Trejos to
establish a sense of credibility and expertise, is verbose and highly detailed explanations. This strategy is implemented throughout the article, but nowhere as potently as the “Methodology” section, which describes the process of the research. One part of the research description, found on page 289, follows:

Loan repayment was set at 50 weekly equal payments, one payment per week (principal plus interest). ALSOL has no institutional rule for declaring a loan in default. We applied a 25-week rule: If no payments were made for 25 consecutive weeks, we declared the loan inactive, and then removed from the loan portfolio. Thus, our data contain 1509 "active loans" and 642 "inactive loans" as of the week of July 2, 2001. Of the 2151 participants, 942 operated out of 49 rural centers, and 1209 operated out of 48 urban centers. We also conducted on-site interviews to a randomly selected sample of 50 participants to learn more about their business practices, economic activities, and overall living conditions.

In describing research it is important to provide as much detail as possible so that the readers will be more likely to trust that the research actually took place and that it is potentially repeatable, or at least can be intricately scrutinized. This level of detail provides accountability and helps ensure legitimacy.
Of course there is a scientifically legitimate reason for providing details in a research article. The study needs to be repeatable and double-checked. But there are two other reasons as well. One, it gives the appearance that you thought out every detail and possibility associated with your project. Obviously you must have put hours and hours of time and thought into it, since there are so many words. But, oh! you forgot something? No worries, you simply state that it was a limitation and include it at the end of your paper as a suggestion for future research. The second reason is that the more words written, the longer the article becomes. Most academic journals have page limits, so you do not want to write too much (which would also give the impression that you are rambling, meaning you do not actually know what you are talking about). However, if the page limit is ten pages, and you write five - well that is just plain embarrassing.
There are certainly legitimate reasons for using the official style in academic writing. The article would never get published without it. Jargon may be necessary to express certain ideas and connect with other experts in the field. References are required to prove validity and that the information is not entirely made up. Meticulous details are needed for others to check the work and repeat it, if needed. So there are very real and very legitimate reasons for using the official style, and it is likely that Barboza and Trejos had these reasons in mind while writing.
It is also likely, however, that the rules of the academic publishing game were in the back of their minds as well. Jargon is necessary otherwise experts will not take the authors seriously. References are demanded if one wants to become part of the insider circle of experts who constantly reference each other. Big words and intricate details are needed to fill pages and look impressive. Legal terminology and jargon, professional references, and complex, meticulous details were used by Barboza and Trejos in the context of this article to produce the effects of credibility and expertise. But can you blame them? Everyone wants to play in the big leagues, and to be allowed on the field you have to follow the rules of the game.

-M.C. Reynolds

Saturday, October 12, 2013

Write Officially, But Don't Write Off an Audience

    
     As a student, I spend hours of each day submersed in texts.  Texts filled with jargon I have been trained to understand and complex ideas that I am expected to pick up on before my class next meets.  While the arguments and topics of these texts vary, one thing is fairly standard across the board, the primary manner in which the central thesis is delivered to the reader of the article is all too frequently a highly elevated technique that alienates readers and obscures arguments.  Or rather, the style used is what is considered the “official style”.  A tone and approach heavily favored by academics, the official style is useful but problematic depending on the audience.  When used sparingly and with clarity, the official style can elevate an argument and lend credibility to an author.  However, this success is only possible if multiple audiences of a text would be able to understand the language used.
            The fluid nature of Literature means that in many cases one novel can attract a wide variety of readers or scholars. Toni Morrison’s body of work holds a beautiful example of this. A black, female, American author, Morrison writes novels about the coming of age of African American women. Her work attracts scholars of Young Adult literature, African American Literature, and Feminist Literature to name just a few.  Jane S. Bakerman’s article “Failures of Love: Female Initiation in the Novels of Toni Morrison” explores the importance of the initial sexual experiences of various characters in Morrison’s works. The article was originally published in American Literature journal, the readers of which cover a wide variety of scholars.  Bakerman uses some aspects of the official style to give herself credibility, and accurately represent her argument.  However, by avoiding other aspects, she doesn't alienate the wide variety of audiences who might be attracted to the research.
            This example found on pages 550-551 of the original article showcases Bakerman’s unique use of the official style very well.
                                   
Throughout the article, Bakerman uses only pieces of the official style at a time.  Here, we see limited jargon, and complex, but to the point, sentences.  Too often, complex sentences use strings of “to be verbs” combined with propositions in order to fit a large number of ideas into a single sentence.  The most complex sentence here is located in the middle and starts “While, in a sense, …” This sentence is long at forty-two words, contains seven verb phrases, but only 1 prepositional phrase.  The sentences itself is difficult to read because of multiple emphasized words.  However, Bakerman contrasts the complex-ness of the sentence with simpler word choices, and keeping a singular idea in focus.  By not using all of the elements of official style simultaneously, Bakerman avoids the alienation of audiences.  Keep in mind that Bakerman uses minimal jargon as well; the most prominent instance is the phrase “preparatory initiation episode” which is explained contextually in the rest of the sentence.  While scholars of Adolescent Literature may be familiar with this idea, those who study other forms might not be.  Once again, Bakerman is using her linguistic skills to allow all audiences to understand the complex concepts presented.   
This example, pulled from much earlier in the article averaged a grading of 11.9, roughly that of an American High School senior. 
                             
The two paragraphs next to each other show that Bakerman is using a wide variety of voices combined with in the article.  In this example, the ideas are moderately complex, but the wording and sentence structure are simple. 24.3 words averaged in 4 sentences puts the example at a higher level than plain text (generally near 7th grade) but below that of what the audience would be assumed to have (14th and higher).  Again, Bakerman makes the effort to not use the more confusing aspects of official style, but instead uses the passive voice and complex sentences with simpler vocabulary and to-the-point emphasis. The Official style is not an enemy of new or seasoned scholars, but rather a tool used by many to add an air of academia to their work.  That is exactly how I took Bakerman’s limited use of the Official style in her article.  She was discussing what could have been a simple idea, and allowed her academic voice to be strong but efficient in representing that idea leading overall to a well formed well represented argument. 

            Initially, when reading the article, I thought that because I study Adolescent Literature and Literature focusing on the “Other” I may have been too close to the core audience to see if Bakerman was alienating with use of the Official style.  However, after looking closely at the well-crafted ideas, I began to understand that Bakerman doesn't alienate the multiple audiences that could be drawn to her work.  Instead, she picks and chooses her sentence construction carefully in order to allow a wide variety of readers to understand an important aspect of Morrison’s body of work.  This is turn means that the cross-pollination of ideas can filter through all Literature Academic Sub-Categories and influence a greater number of scholars.  

R. R. Watson 

Friday, October 11, 2013

Official Style Forcing the Issue in Educational Discourse

The field of education is always looking to move forward in theory, pedagogy, and practice, and the most common method for proposing these new ideas comes through published research in peer-reviewed academic journals. This learned community shares and evaluates ideas that are then utilized by not only teachers and administrators, but by pre-service teachers and students alike. This community relies on a certain level of groundwork knowledge that all involved in the field will have a basic knowledge of, and these ideas circulate throughout the professional discourse. One such piece of information that is currently relevant is the Common Core State Standards, which have been adopted in most states as the basis for knowledge based curriculum in public schools. These standards have opened the door for a large amount of discussion on best implementation practices, with a large amount of variety on the techniques most advised.
One journal that prides itself on being on the cutting edge of educational reform and ideas is the journal of “American Secondary Education,” published three times per year by Ashland University Dwight Schar College of Education. Writing exclusively on current issues, this journal is one of the few that publishes research and articles on contemporary topics in secondary education in America. It comes as no surprise then, that the article “Young Adult Literature and The Common Core: A Surprisingly Good Fit,” written by J. Ostenson and R. Wadham, would appear in the pages of this journal. Addressing two hot-button issues in contemporary education, Young Adult Literature (YA Lit) and The Common Core State Standards (CCSS), this article raises the issues that contemporary teachers and administrators would be keenly aware of within their own schools. This article could help if they were actively seeking out solutions to these problems.
“Young Adult Literature and The Common Core” focuses on the main ways that YA Lit can be used to meet the CCSS goals for literature, and also argues that YA Lit should supplant the traditional texts used in secondary schools across America. The authors argue that YA Lit engages students in texts, and is a better way for young readers to see themselves in Literature and to gain an appreciation for Literature. Proposing an idea that will challenge the traditional concept of Literature education in
educational philosophy, the authors are putting two different perspectives in contradiction. These perspectives are two prominent schools of thought in educational philosophy, traditional and progressive. Traditional thinkers are likely to be resistant to the change that is suggested by the goal of this argument, which would remove the traditional approach of using canonical literature. Replacing this standard would be progressive approach, as teachers would begin to use more YA Lit in the
classroom. Therefore, it would appear that the authors, despite having a valid argument, already will face a challenge in reversing a dominant, longstanding belief on the best practice of teaching literature.
In addition to that challenge, the authors’ prose in the piece also seems to work to undermine their argument. By employing a steady use of euphemisms to refer to student ability, they hope to convey an additional sense of importance to their work, hoping to establish extra credibility for their claims. They also appear, again through euphemisms, as well as verbose prose and complex structuring, to hope to impress the peer reviewers who decide whether an article is fit for publishing. Despite these prose based drawbacks, the piece itself still functions well as an argument for their intended audience, due to the audience’s familiarity with these techniques being utilized in Educational Literature, and their understanding that arguments like these are needed to advance the field of education.
It’s worth considering, however, that the intended audience of this piece has multiple aspects and perspectives. Two communities involved in this discourse are pre-service teachers hoping to flesh out their understanding of the educational field, and current teachers looking for ways to change their approach to education that best aligns with contemporary theory. These communities would be more likely to focus on the parts of the arguments that contain valid, usable information, and be less active in critiquing the work. Two other, more involved levels of community are those creating the discourse, and those who are reviewing and evaluating the texts. These groups would be more active in noticing weaknesses in arguments, and would be more active in critiquing the text’s value as compared to other artifacts and ideas in the discourse community. We can assume that the faults in the prose would have a different effect on these different communities, and would alter how different people react to the ideas in the text.
Looking at one specific sample of prose, we can point out several of the features of prose style that the authors use that threaten to weaken their argument.

“Perhaps the most important goal identified by the CCSS is developing independent readers who can interpret complex texts on their own. Here again, YA literature can help because it ameliorates some of the challenges that classic literature poses to teens (A) (Gallo, 2001; Santoli & Wagner, 2004) while maintaining a sophisticated treatment of themes and characters (B). By providing our young students with accessible and relevant texts, YA literature encourages students to read more and gives them the confidence that they can independently navigate complex texts (C).”


In underlined segment (A), the authors are stating why the believe YA Lit is important for usage in schools, because it helps reduce the issues that students have when addressing difficult texts. However, when discussing, in underlined segment (B), their use of the official style seems to contradict their claim. By framing YA Lit as “maintaining a sophisticated treatment of themes and characters,” one wonders if this study is any easier than those of classic literature. The overinflated euphemism used detracts from the point they wish to make, that YA Lit is easier to understand, yet also address the same literary techniques. By framing it in such a verbose manner, the authors appear to be looking for ways to make their argument stronger without providing support, a cheap way to gain credibility.
And in underlined section (C), the authors make an euphemistic claim through the official style, that appears to lend importance to the phrase. Yet in the context of the sentence, the phrase means little more than ‘read hard books by themselves.’ Again their use of the official style to look for extra credibility seems to undermine their assertion that YA Lit is actually more effective due to the ease of access that it can offer younger readers. In the next selection from the text, we again see the authors using euphemism to add a heightened sense of importance or meaning to their phrases, even though they would already accomplish their goal without the added components.
In examining the next selection, the underlined sections will focus on areas that the authors use the official style in hopes of adding importance and lending credibility to their stance.
The arrival of the CCSS provides a significant opportunity to reexamine practice and the goals we have for developing literate graduates. As teachers seek to build classrooms where students are engaged in meaningful, authentic activities related to reading, the Common Core provides solid standards to pursue. We encourage teachers and administrators to consider strongly the role that young adult literature can play in meeting these standards, especially in terms of the complexity of texts we should be using with students. Young adult literature can satisfy the demands for quantitative and qualitative complexity along with the canonical pieces of literature that have traditionally dominated instruction in classrooms. Moreover, this genre holds significant potential to motivate young readers and to provide them with meaningful contexts in which to practice and refine the important literacy skills they will need to be successful, independent, and skilled readers.

In each instance, the authors include an unneeded modifier in a phrase, even though the idea would stand alone without the modifier. This extra emphasis has the role of adding urgency and importance to the argument, by stressing the authors views. The large amount of modifiers creates an elevated style of prose, which the authors hope will drive the audience to consider them experts on this topic, and will lend them credibility. Believing this is needed to have their uncommon, progressive view upheld as the correct way to approach literature, the authors are manipulating their readers stance on the argument through the official style.
Because the progressive view is hoping to gain footing as the dominant perspective in education, the authors’ use of the official style seems to reflect a belief that they must force the issue, and make their ideas as important and relevant as possible. Using the official style to inflate the importance of their argument threatens to weaken the overall effectiveness of the piece, however, the argument is still effective for certain audiences. This is because the communities involved in this tension will react differently to the ideas. Many of the high school and preservice teachers that will encounter this text will be inclined to the progressive ideal, and will find the argument important enough to overlook some attempts by the authors to overstress their perspective.
The other parts of the community interacting with this text may also overlook the authors’ stretch for relevance due to the journal it is published in, which supports new ideas that push the forefront of educational theory. So while the authors may seem to over inflate their importance, that is their strategy for establishing the relevance of their argument, and for this find themselves more likely published in journals like “American Secondary Education.” To impress others who are creating and judging discourses being produced for this journal, the authors’ need to find a way to set their argument apart, even if it’s by creating a sense of importance that is not inherently carried.

Finally, the authors avoid most other elements of official style throughout their writing, managing to strike a balance between straightforward prose at some points, and euphemistic, insider-language based prose at others. So while J. Ostenson and R. Wadham at times threaten to undermine the inherent importance of their topic with the overbearing presence of the official style, the topic’s importance eventually wins out. As long as the reader is aware of the authors’ attempts to stress their viewpoint’s importance, they will be able to decode the inclusions of the official style and make realistic judgements on the texts importance for themselves. 

by: Brandon Noble

Monday, May 13, 2013

The Incredible Sound of Silence


            “The Sound of Silence” is a song released by Simon and Garfunkel in 1964. It was a turbulent and revolutionary time for a new kind of generation to be coming of age. The history of the United States from the early 1960s to around 1980 included many dramatic events which forever changed the American lifestyle. The 1960s were marked with protests for African-American civil rights, the end of the Vietnam War, feminist activism, a revolt for political change, lifestyle security and pleas for peace. There is a more complete reference page for history from 1964 through 1980 available on Wikipedia based on the depths of each one of these individual and important revolutions (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_United_States_(1964%E2%80%9380)). At the young age of twenty-one, Paul Simon took six months to write the lyrics to a song that has become intrinsically linked to decades of people and American culture. “The Sound of Silence” has not only sealed its position as a piece of American classic rock but also continues to attract and promote its message to new generations in order to continue its legacy. The song has transcended almost 50 years through its use of imagery, structure, meaning and artistry.
            The song begins with an apostrophe, a rhetorical device to address something real or imaginary. “Hello darkness my old friend, I’ve come to talk with you again,” immediately sets a tone of alienation for the speaker. By saying “my old friend” suggests this is not the first time he has found himself alone without the comfort of communication with another person. There is no specifically addressed reason as to why he feels isolation. This vague idea of being caught feeling alienated is likely to be felt relevant by a majority of people. The verse continues with “Because a vision softly creeping, Left its seeds while I was sleeping. And that vision that was planted in my brain, still remains, within the sounds of silence.” The “vision” is still only referred to as a “seed” so it is not yet any sort of complete thought; however, it is still trapped “within the sound of silence.” The silence can be seen as amplification to the idea that the thought is not only incomplete but also completely absent of a function. His “vision” is still in an imaginative space where it can express a power to serve many functions, including the ability to open new possibilities among people, but it is caught within his mind and not shared with others.
            The first verse opens the song and introduces the feeling of isolation despite being around others. The author of the words is aware of his alienation from others like he is waking from a dream. In the third verse he attempts to summarize his ideas about the people around his life and in society. “People talking without speaking. People hearing without listening.” The repetition of these two short phrases immediately following each other highlights the meaninglessness of words when nobody cares to pay attention. The weight of a life-changing “vision” cannot serve any function if it is not openly expressed and then openly accepted by others. If “people are talking without speaking” or “hearing without listening,” they are no longer balancing their ideas against the influences and lifestyles in society. Paul Simon has always claimed this idea seems to be a “young thought” but that does not remove any importance or sophistication from the concept. It is more likely to be considered a “young thought” because of the activity systems influencing younger generations.
           All generations of youths experience a time of learning, experiencing and testing of boundaries. Exposure to the luxuries of college, or even just time to grow and come of age, makes a generation optimistic in their ability to create change. This was immensely true for the generation creating change in the 1960s and 70s. Between war, racial and sexual discrimination, and the need to create change, it can often feel like no one is listening. These ideas remain current throughout generations because life is hard. Fifty years later, all generations have war, discrimination, inequality and challenges. No one wants to settle for only what may have been predestined for them in life. Generations rebel against the systems of inequality they do not agree with in their lives. The feeling of alienation comes from the sense of people’s lack of communication and their own feelings about the inability to change an already created system. If everyone shared their experiences and were open enough to rethink through them, it would become more possible to create focus and change the nature of society. He closes his third verse with “And no one dared, disturb the sound of silence.” It gives more meaning to the difficulties facing the creation of change if no one is willing to be the change they want to see.
           By the fourth verse, the anger and the frustration facing the “vision” begins to show. “Fools, said I, you do not know, Silence like a cancer grows.” Beginning this verse with the expletive of “fools” details the frustration of how it feels for him to want to give people an understanding but it is blocked by an inability he cannot control. Blender Magazine puts this song at number 60 on a list of worst songs ever because they feel the lyric is too self-important. This is the exact ability of creative rhetoric because the value of the finished project can be weighed and criticized like art. Saying “silence like a cancer grows,” is another use of creative rhetoric by making the simile between silence and cancer. He feels if the silence is not addressed then it will continue to spread and disease the society. The verse flows with rhyming words, also called homoioptoton, for creating lyrics with similar sounds ending in parallel words. I will highlight the rhymes in color for my reader to reference.
"Fools", said I, "You do not know
Silence like a cancer
grows
Hear my words that I might
teach you
Take my arms that I might
reach you"
But my words, like silent raindrops fell
And echoed
In the wells of silence

And the people bowed and prayed
To the neon god they
made
And the sign flashed out its
warning
In the words that it was
forming
And the sign said, "The words of the prophets are written on the subway
walls
And tenement
halls"
And whispered in the sounds of silence
The continuing repetition of the word silence is used in every verse and is of greatest importance because it is the key idea for purpose in this song.
            The final verse creates a strong metaphor about the people’s behavior at the time. It says “And the people bowed and prayed, To the neon God they made.” This illustrates a population’s dependence on everything new, shiny and of commercial value only. Even in 1960, corporations and marketing were beginning to create and influence the culture of America. However, this lyric from almost 50 years ago could almost be given a higher value today than in the past. Our American culture is obsessed with commercial consumption. Our reliance on all things technological creates even more problems with communication when it comes down to a group already being together socially and still having the need to check on their own technology links. This sort of communication keeps everyone busy, but never really burrows into the depths of true balanced thinking and listening. The future should have made communication easier with convenience and accessibility. Instead it almost seems to be a downfall of constant distractions keeping the population’s thoughts occupied with trivial matters instead of revolutionary work. Paul Simon was trying through art to make an acknowledgment between what is said and what is experienced. This level of truth continues to resonate with any listener fortunate enough to find themselves on the receiving end of the speakers for “The Sound of Silence.”
Keeley McConaughey