Thursday, March 27, 2014

Abraham Lincoln: An Official Style and Rhetorical Genius

The Emancipation Proclamation: a speech that was given in 1863 by Abraham Lincoln. We know the Emancipation Proclamation as a major point in Lincoln’s presidency. We also think it gave freedom to all African-American slaves, and it abolished slavery in the future. But perhaps we lose sight of the truth because the Official Style is so prominent in the Emancipation Proclamation. In the 1800s, people spoke more officially than people speak now in the 2000s. However, this document is especially Official, compared to informal letters in the later 1800s that I researched. There is plenty of important historical context surrounding the Emancipation Proclamation that helps us to understand why Lincoln chose to sign this Official Style document into law.  Regardless of Lincoln’s exact motives, I’m going to argue that Lincoln used Official Style characteristics, such as scesis onomaton, sentential adverbs, and lengthy, complex sentences to gain authority and trust from the newly freed slaves and also the constituents of Lincoln’s side in the Civil War, the North.
            First of all, it’s important to explain the historical context behind the Emancipation Proclamation. With a little research, you can find this document was created in the midst of the Civil War, and Lincoln was under a lot of pressure. The nation was divided, and southern states were seceding. Interestingly enough, it is often believed by historians that Lincoln was actually a racist. Why would Lincoln free slaves if he was in fact a racist? And even if he was not a racist, why would he make such a controversial decision? As USA Today describes, “It was the product of a most difficult decision by a most complex president during a most crucial conflict. It ordered the largest single confiscation of private property in U.S. history.” They go on to suggest, “[The Emancipation Proclamation] ensured Lincoln his spot in the American pantheon.” Did Lincoln do it for the recognition? Did he do it because it was the morally right choice? We will never truly know the answer to why Lincoln decided to sign this into law to end slavery. 
It is important to acknowledge two not very well-known details about the Emancipation Proclamation. First of all, this proclamation did not free all slaves. It only freed slaves in states that had seceded from the Union. Directly from the Proclamation, Abraham announces all states in which slaves are emancipated and he mentions, “ Louisiana, (except the Parishes of St. Bernard, Plaquemines, Jefferson, St. John, St. Charles, St. James Ascension, Assumption, Terrebonne, Lafourche, St. Mary, St. Martin, and Orleans, including the City of New Orleans).” Those exceptions prove that not all slaves were given freedom. A second detail is that the Emancipation Proclamation did not exactly give freedom to African-Americans. As history shows, African-Americans were still oppressed and not given full freedom until the later half of the 19th century. If people had been able to know these two facts when Lincoln issued this proclamation, many might have viewed it as a pointless law. Therefore, Lincoln had to cover up these details without lying in a legal document, while also creating a trustworthy, authoritative image of himself for the newly “freed slaves”, who were probably not that educated, and for his previous constituents. This is where the Official Style comes into play.
            The Official Style characteristic I see the most in this document is scesis onomaton, emphasis through constant repetition of words. After the narrative introduction, the first paragraph starts, “That on the first day of January, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and sixty-three, all persons held as slaves within any State or designated part of a State, the people whereof shall then be in rebellion against the United States,” The second paragraph then starts, “That the Executive will, on the first day of January aforesaid, by proclamation, designate the States and parts of States, if any, in which the people thereof, respectively, shall then be in rebellion against the United States; and the fact that any State, or the people thereof, shall on that day be, in good faith, represented in the Congress of the United States” These two sentences are practically identical. They express almost the exact same idea, except at the end of sentence one, Lincoln issues freedom, and at the end of sentence two, Lincoln issues legal protection.
The third paragraph, also goes on to state nearly the same thing, “On this first day of January, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and sixty-three, and in accordance with my purpose so to do publicly proclaimed for the full period of one hundred days, from the day first above mentioned, order and designate as the States and parts of States wherein the people thereof respectively, are this day in rebellion against the United States, the following…” The exception here is at the end of this sentence; Lincoln announces all the specific states where slaves will be freed. In all three of these examples, the same long phrases are used as emphasis. With emphasis on the day, month year, Lincoln’s duty, etc., the newly proclaimed information gets hidden at the end of the sentence.  I argue that people get lost in the time it takes him to introduce each new law, legal protection, freedom, and freedom in certain states for former slaves.
            A second trait of the Emancipation Proclamation that screams Official Style is the sentential adverbs. This document is loaded with words used just for fillers. The first word of the document is “Whereas”, and this sets the tone for the rest of it. Throughout Lincoln’s speech we hear all of the following sentential adverbs: therefore, aforeword, henceworth, thereof, hereby, whereof, hereunto, wherein, thereto, and thenceforward. I’m not sure I understand some of these words… Henceworth? Thenceforward? If I can’t understand these long, combined words, how might the average slave or even average citizen member be able to thoroughly understand this proclamation with every few words being a sentential adverb. These adverbs are definitely filler words… words Lincoln used to distract his audience-the likely uneducated, newly freed slaves and people of the North- and also create an image that would make Lincoln seem smart, and therefore trustworthy, especially to the majorly uneducated former slaves.
            A third Official Style aspect found in this document is the sheer length and complexity of sentences. There are only 9 sentences in the Emancipation Proclamation, and there are 697 words. That averages out to 77 words per sentence! These sentences are too loaded and wordy for common citizens to follow without losing focus. Each sentence is fully clad with semi colons, colons, comma, dashes, and everything of the like that could possibly extend a sentence. This is the longest sentence throughout the whole document:

“Now, therefore I, Abraham Lincoln, President of the United States, by virtue of the power in me vested as Commander-in-Chief, of the Army and Navy of the United States in time of actual armed rebellion against the authority and government of the United States, and as a fit and necessary war measure for suppressing said rebellion, do, on this first day of January, in the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and sixty-three, and in accordance with my purpose so to do publicly proclaimed for the full period of one hundred days, from the day first above mentioned, order and designate as the States and parts of States wherein the people thereof respectively, are this day in rebellion against the United States, the following, to wit:
Arkansas, Texas, Louisiana, (except the Parishes of St. Bernard, Plaquemines, Jefferson, St. John, St. Charles, St. James Ascension, Assumption, Terrebonne, Lafourche, St. Mary, St. Martin, and Orleans, including the City of New Orleans) Mississippi, Alabama, Florida, Georgia, South Carolina, North Carolina, and Virginia, (except the forty-eight counties designated as West Virginia, and also the counties of Berkley, Accomac, Northampton, Elizabeth City, York, Princess Ann, and Norfolk, including the cities of Norfolk and Portsmouth[)], and which excepted parts, are for the present, left precisely as if this proclamation were not issued.”

That sentence is 218 words long. How is anyone supposed to follow a sentence this long without becoming distracted? Not only do these long sentences make Lincoln sound extremely smart to the average person, but the length and complexity of these sentences hide the fact that in this one sentence, Lincoln admits that not all slaves will be freed. Only slaves in those listed states were freed. However, Lincoln’s supporters and the freed slaves in this time period would likely think Lincoln is smart and he abolished slavery, so he is kind- therefore, trustworthy.
            Through the long, complex sentences, sentential adverbs, and scesis onomaton it is evident to me that Lincoln was using the Official Style to gain authority, trust, and recognition. He persuade his constituents, including the newly freed slaves, to support him enough to re-elect him in the next, and we all know the Emancipation Proclamation exists as major point in U.S. history. I believe this was Lincoln’s goal and he succeeded well.

A copy of the Emancipation Proclamation can be accessed here: http://www.archives.gov/exhibits/featured_documents/emancipation_proclamation/transcript.html

Information cited from the USA Today article can be accessed here: http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2012/12/25/lincolns-emancipation-move-still-sparks-debate/1791025/

By: Cody Fortney


Acorns, Embryos and The Official Style


Acorns, Embryos and The Official Style
When composing a document of any sort you must first ask yourself a few questions. Who is my audience? Is it broad or narrow? Am I writing to a certain demographic, or to readers in general? Also, what is the purpose of my writing? Am I trying to persuade or inform? More often than not audience and style may come into contact, and may even contradict one another. In the case of the paper that I am going to be analyzing and critiquing, two different components compete, and butt heads. The overwhelming question is; will official style and persuasive voice be able to successfully work together, or will one overcome the other?
            Whether in support of, opposed to, or even completely withdrawn from the topic, most Americans would agree that the topic of stem cell research, and the use of embryos to do so is a controversial, and often an emotionally charged subject. When writing an article or paper that deals with a subject of a controversial nature, the official style is a key component in sounding educated and scholarly.  The main goal with any controversial topic is usually to persuade an audience one way or another. The paper that I will be analyzing comes from a scientific journal called The New Atlantis: A Journal of Technology and Society, and the paper is dutifully named Acorns and Embryos.  According to the journal’s website, “The New Atlantis is an effort to clarify the nation’s moral and political understanding of all areas of technology — from stem cells to hydrogen cells to weapons of mass destruction.” The authors Robert George and Patrick Lee take a scientific and technological viewpoint on a long-standing emotionally driven topic, and their goal is to persuade their audience to agree with their viewpoints. The purpose of their paper was to dispute another argument made by two members of the President’s Council on Bioethics published in the New England Journal of Medicine. This article features a few distinct characteristics of the official style, and has many pertinent examples that I will be discussing as well as critiquing.  The question at hand is just how well do the official style and persuasive voice work together to convince the target audience, and to sway them one way or another?
            When considering characteristics of the official style one that is frequently used is the incorporation of jargon into text. Jargon can be defined as “special words or expressions that are used by a particular profession or group and are difficult for others to understand.” In this specific article jargon is widely used, and may be widely understood by a certain demographic of people. However, if the authors are attempting to persuade an average reader, the use of jargon simply creates a divide. One clear example of jargon within the article reads, “But what about the claims of Paul McHugh? Is there a morally relevant difference between blastocysts that come into being by the union of gametes and those that are produced by somatic cell nuclear transfer?” When considering jargon usage you must first examine who the target audience is. If the audience is broad, the “average reader,” will more than likely be dumbfounded as to the definition of blastocysts,  gametes, and possibly even somatic cell nuclear transfer unless they are well read in the areas of biology and the human reproductive system. The authors go on to write, “Even if human embryos are nothing other than embryonic human beings, as we argue and McHugh agrees, are “clonotes” something other than human embryos?” If the authors were to put these words in laymen’s terms everyday readers, or people who are not well learned in the academic areas of biology and genetics would be much more engaged and interested in the argument being presented. When determining whom the target audience is, the answer is simply not as cut and dry as it may seem. There are two very different demographics that may be reading this piece, one academic and specifically designated group of scholars that particularly focus on the topics and hand, and another very different demographic that simply wants to learn more on the subject of stem cell research. These two examples of jargon exemplify the idea that when using the official language, jargon is pertinent and frequently used. Although within the bioethics community this language may be standard, for those that are outside of this circle this language may only result in confusion, frustration and a clear demographic divide.
            One final use of the official style within this article focuses on word choice, and tone. The authors of the article are dealing with an emotionally charged topic, and are attempting to persuade their audience to agree with their viewpoints. However, consider this example and try to decipher what the authors are attempting to accomplish. The authors write; “The dispute would properly be characterized as a debate about the ethics of killing retarded children to harvest their vital organs. The issue could not be resolved by considering how many gravely ill non-retarded people could be saved by extracting a heart, two kidneys, and a liver from each retarded child. The threshold question would be whether it is unjust to relegate a certain class of human beings — the retarded — to the status of objects that can be killed and dissected to benefit others.” This passage is extremely confusing, and hard to read. Not only are the authors speaking in verbose language, and making their argument lengthier than necessary by incorporating words like threshold, and phrases such as, “properly be characterized”, but also their chosen word choice is inappropriate, and awkward. Although the authors are arguing against embryonic stem cell research, and are incorporating scientific approaches and technical language into their argument, when doing so shouldn’t they use a more scientific term than “retarded?” Their overall tone is cold, removed and unattached from the subject, which completely contradicts their purpose in writing the piece. What are the authors’ objectives when phrasing their argument this way? What do they hope to achieve? The lack of a warm, concerned and compassionate tone may be a successful example of the impersonal tone often used when writing in the official style, but it fails at presenting a persuasive voice.
            Although the main purpose of this article is to dispute other scholars views and beliefs, the arguments presented would have been portrayed more successfully if many of the elements of the official style were absent, and replaced with more personal, and relatable word choices and examples. On one hand it is always appealing for authors to write in a way that is acceptable and welcomed in the world of academia, and to appear scholarly and well read on a subject. On the other hand, if the target audience is a much wider demographic, all jargon, and inappropriate word choice succeeds at doing is creating discourse. The authors of this article were attempting to persuade an audience to agree with their opinions. However, isn’t it easier to persuade a person, or audience if you are able to make connections with the reader? By using jargon, unnecessary language, and an impersonal tone the authors may succeed more so at confusing their day to day readers, rather than convincing them. Although the official style is an important part of the English language, one must consider the main goal of their writing when determining whether the official or plain style is more appropriate.

Madeline Marquardt

Wednesday, March 26, 2014

Critiquing the Official Style in Practice

            The journal Psychological Science is a publication created for and maintained by the Association for Psychological Science.  This group of individuals, previously known as the American Psychological Society represents a not-for-profit organization that is dedicated to the advancement of scientific psychology and its representation at both the national and international levels. The organization was founded in 1988 and currently has approximately 26,000 members of varying professions including scientists, academics, clinicians, researchers, teachers and administrators. As an activity system, the journal strives to keep their readership informed about changes and advancements in the field of psychology and related matters.  This online journal alternates between being an open access platform and having articles hidden behind a pay-wall.  For example, the article entitled Inhibition Drives Early Feature-Based Attention, which is the subject of this critique, was initially available in its entirety online and was located after performing a simple Google search. Now, the article is hidden behind a pay-wall that provides several different fee options in order to view the article. In changing the access to the article the information included, the style in which the article was written and the uses of the article are all cast into a new light.

            The article discusses an experiment that was designed by Jeff Moher, Balaji M. Lakshmanan, Howard E. Egeth, and Joshua B. Ewen and conducted by J. Moher and B.M. Lakshmanan to test how visual processing is affected by outside stimuli and distractions.            J. Moher wrote the initial manuscript and all contributed to the final publication. All of the authors are professionals in the field of psychology working either in the university setting or for a private institution designed to assist individuals with developmental disorders. Because Psychological Science is a peer-reviewed journal, articles published are intended first and foremost to be of assistance to their membership. Accounting for this fact, one would expect the language used to be extremely formal and the scores on any readability test to reflect the advanced level of schooling that all involved have accomplished. However after the completing a readability test on several sections of the article, the abstract earned the highest score averaging a grade level of 14.7 amongst the various measures and a Flesch-Kincaid Reading Ease score of 27.8 which means it is best  understood by university graduates though the Flesch-Kincaid grade level only places the abstract at 13.9 grade level.

            The inconsistency in grade level assessment is in large part due to the syntax of the article.  The words employed are often familiar if irregularly used.  While there is vocabulary that is specific to the field of sight and mental capacity this is presented in context and without additional clarification owning to the fact that this article was written for fellows in the field who would be familiar with and expect such jargon. Words that are familiar are used to describe larger concepts such as visual input, visual processing and sensory processing used to describe sight or seeing. Using these terms to express a fairly simple concept does two things: it lends credibility to the authors as professionals in their field and also allows specific elements of visual processing to be discussed, from initial exposure to the time the image is processed by the test subject.  However, in using this language, the authors have also created an additional barrier to any in the general public, as is shown by the Flesch-Kincaid readability score.

            This article details an experiment that could have important implications for the way people respond to stimulus, and based on the researcher’s professional and academic credentials their interest seems to be focused on individuals with special needs.  Information as to how to assist children with special needs is often required by those outside of the academic world.  Often parents or educators working with a child may not have the resources to seek help from a professional institution and would benefit from the results of this experiment being presented in an easy to understand manner.  The information would also be beneficial to the general public to make people aware of reaction time irregularities that may exist and to help avoid potentially hazardous situations.

            In addition to the official style over-complicating the explanation of a simple process like seeing, the pay-wall is also a further barrier to the information being provided to a larger audience. Information about the way people process the things that they see can be useful in a myriad of different situations, from driving tests to both the production and the purchasing sides of manufacturing. If presented in a manner that more people could comprehend without having to do additional research or re-read sections of the article to obtain the meaning, the information could have long-reaching effects, not because the experiment told us something new and interesting but because it answers questions science was already asking about the way we perceive our world.
http://pss.sagepub.com/content/25/2/315.full



Vanessa Kocar

Tuesday, March 25, 2014

Official Style and Obamacare


                                                  Official Style and Obamacare
In Obamacare, lawmakers lay out the elements of “official style “. It said that style of writing is characterized by passive voice, complex sentences, verbose and jargonistic. As generally, the official style is used by legal and business document, the scientific articles, and the diplomacy. People complain that they cannot totally understand the meaning of text if using official style. As generally, ordinary people will not read these documents which helps readers to sleep unless they have special cause. Although it cannot be completely accepted by the public, it still exists in formal writing. I think, because this style has a definite communication aim and accordingly has its own system of interrelated language and stylistic means. This main aim of this type of communication is to state the conditions binding two parties in undertaking. In other words, it is not for anyone to read.
We view this legal document as an activity system. The lawmakers is  the subject of this activity system. What lawmakers write is super formal, which make the readers believe its authority and credibility. In some way, it can reduce questions toward the document, because it is not easy to find out flaws for ordinary people. Therefore, it limits the range of readers to read and explore. Now we discuss what strategies of official style obstruct people to read. Let’s take a look at an excerpt from a section of the patient protection and affordable care act:
“The insurance-related terms described in this paragraph are premium, deductible, co-insurance, co-payment, out-of-pocket limit, preferred provider, non-preferred provider, out-of-network co-payments, UCR (usual, customary and reasonable) fees, excluded services, grievance and appeals, and such other terms as the Secretary determines are important to define so that consumers may compare health insurance coverage and understand the terms of their coverage.”
Except passive voice often used in formal writing, it also uses the strategies of verbose, slow sentences opening, complex sentences, and jargonistic. For passive voice, we see two examples, “terms described in” and “the secretary determines are important”. For verbose, I think, it easily observes that the sentence structure complacent habits of a large, Impersonal, arbitrary bureaucracy. So many compound words make the long sentences that let people think it is really “professional”. For the slow sentences opening, we see that the beginning of sentence is short, having seven words, “the insurance-related terms described in this paragraph”. But the number of words in the whole sentence is fifty-seven. For the jargonistic, I find out a word, like “UCR” which is a term that the certain group people can understand. When I look for the meaning of UCR, I find that UCR has more than twelve translations in Wiki. But within this context, the appropriate definition is “usual, customary and reasonable, a method of generating health care prices.” If it doesn’t mention its meaning behind the word, how many people can understand its specific meaning? It is the exclusive right of experts. It causes difficulties for ordinary people to read. But for some people, such as the lawmakers, the worker of insurance company, it is easy for them to understand, or it is succinct that they might think of.
I think, it is not the fault of official style itself. It is a style of language that is created by society. But people are the practice subject of social activities. So we question that, why people have to use unpopular official style? According to the average reading grade of Americans, it is bond to the reading difficulty of Americans who don’t accept higher education. The official style has a definite communication aim literally and accordingly has its own system of interrelated language and stylistic means. This main aim of this style is to state conditions binding two discourses. Two discourse like the state government and citizens. The purpose of stating conditions is to reach agreement. For example, the Phone Company has contact with users. You have to sign up after reading the conditions. They make a deal with Phone Company. Sometimes, some conditions is a barrier to the non-experts. It leads to a cheat literally. But some people play well this game, they will not be fooled. Therefore, we can see the differences among people, at least you know their education level. We question that, will it become a circle that people who have lower education never understand official style? If so, the using of official style will lead to social inequality. And the inequality mainly reflects on the social class.
The book of the social stratification of English in New York City written by William Labov, has an interesting discovery. The higher socio-economic status position, the higher their pronunciation of retroflex. Similarly, in British English, we can find out more examples to prove the different habit of using words at varying levels. If you cannot understand what others said, as generally people say “sorry”, not “pardon”. Because “pardon” means the forgiveness from upper class to prisoners. The other example is that, the middle class of British people will not say “I go home”, they will say “I go to my house”. So there is the differences between social stratification. I see, the Obama’s speech is not the same thing as the Hillary Clinto’s speech. After all, they represent different social groups in the United States.

                                                                                                                        Jingyu Liang

Does the Official Style in Feminist Studies Contribute to Inequality?

I’m not exactly sure when the official style of writing became an everyday occurrence in my life. I likely saw simplified versions of it in high school in my drier textbooks, not that they were read often, but today, as a college senior, I expect nothing less than my assigned readings to challenge not only my understanding of the world, but also my reading ability. While I usually feel a sense of accomplishment after reading and engaging with a difficult, official document, more often than not, I’m inclined to skip the reading and peruse Facebook, or at best, do a Wikipedia search for a shorter, simplified version on the topic. Occasionally, I attempt to actually read the difficult article, only to find that I still need to do my own research just to understand what I read.
            I’ve found that in classes where one specific interpretation is highly important, reading assignments will be simple and to the point, or if I’m lucky, authored from personal experience. Perhaps this is what drew me, in part, to fields in the humanities, like Women’s Studies, English, and Communication Studies. When I was handed a textbook full of personal essays and creative nonfiction in my intro to women, gender, and sexuality studies course, this change of pace caused me to pause and really soak in the authors’ words, especially when I was used to skimming through 30-page dense articles in which I was lost by the third sentence. It’s not laziness, necessarily, that makes this type of reading more desirable; it’s the literature’s accessibility.
            As I near the end of my college career and enter upper level courses, I have noticed that my ‘fun’ classes (mostly those in the field of Women’s Studies) are getting more difficult and dry. My homework involves more theory, academic writing, and research studies. No longer does the reading feel close to home—it suddenly feels removed and foreign. I am fortunate because I already have the background knowledge needed to understand the basic premise of the readings, due to previous classes. I am also in a position where I have resources to help me get through the material—like peers and professors.
            While I sometimes absolutely dread having to take hours of my day to work through such difficult articles, I understand their importance to the discipline. Without the formulation of theories, we wouldn’t have research, and without patterns found in research we wouldn’t have a reason to study inequality. However, the points made in these articles are so important that they need to reach a broader audience. Because the texts are complicated by use of the official style of writing, they limit who is capable of comprehending them and therefore making use of the knowledge.
I have selected a sample of writing that was assigned to me in class that I found particularly challenging to illustrate this argument. It is titled Speaking to the Past:  Feminist Historiography in Rhetoric, written by Dr. Susan C. Jarratt, who has studied rhetoric, history, and feminist theory and pedagogy. Here is a small sample from this text:
“We should learn from feminist historians in literary studies that the relations of feminist history to "history" should not be only additive. Writing women into history "implies not only a new history of women, but also a new history." Scott points out the need for theoretical synthesis of descriptive cast studies. Without such rhetorizing, marginalization, seems almost inevitable: history of rhetoric here, women's history of rhetoric over there. In Joan Kelly's terms, "compensatory history" is not enough. Gender as a category--i.e. as constitutive of social relations and as a way of signifying power--allows for more than an addition: it shakes up dominant disciplinary concepts. Gender is relational: a history conceived in terms of gender as an analytic differs from "women's history" in that it investigates the ways social categories are constituted around or in the absence of each other” (p. 22).
What I learned in class the day after this reading was assigned were the main points of Jarratt’s article. What this piece (in its entirety) is saying comes down to a few basic points:  first, history is written by men—they are the “dominant culture.” Second, history is no more than a socially constructed narrative. Third, bringing feminist voices into history won’t just add to it, they will change history entirely. Finally we need to break down hierarchies within the feminist movement if we want to break down hierarchies altogether.
With such basic and fairly simple ideas, why was this so difficult for me? First, the author was very fond of name-dropping (which I mostly omitted from the excerpt). For people who study the history of feminism in rhetoric, these names are probably pretty useful. When Jarratt cites these particular people, she is giving herself credibility in these elite circles of scholars who know everything about historical rhetoric and feminism. For the average undergraduate scholar like myself, however, skipping over five long names every few sentences and parenthetical citations every other word gets old quickly. It’s distracting and it doesn’t help me understand the topic.
            It’s not just Jarratt’s use of name-dropping that makes her writing hard to read. She also writes in a very dense way, fitting as much information into a short amount of space as possible. Take these two sentences, for example: “Gender as a category--i.e. as constitutive of social relations and as a way of signifying power--allows for more than an addition: it shakes up dominant disciplinary concepts. Gender is relational: a history conceived in terms of gender as an analytic differs from "women's history" in that it investigates the ways social categories are constituted around or in the absence of each other.” Not only does Jarratt use jargon excessively, she also takes abstract concepts and discusses them in long, complex sentences—complete with dashes and colons. Mainly, however, my frustration with Jarratt’s writing style has everything to do with content. How can someone who is very clearly passionate about feminism, which is, at its core, all about inclusion, be so exclusive? The ideas in this Jarratt’s writing may spark an entirely new way of thinking, which can be hard, but they’re extremely important for people to understand.
            As a kid, I was a really good student. I was in “gifted” programs, I scored well on standardized tests, and I was generally pretty compliant (maybe aside from being a little too chatty with my friends). I’d still like to believe this is true. I may have disliked the work that went along with going to school as a child, but I really didn’t dislike any subject—aside from history.
            You see, no one questions what they learn in school as children. We’re taught that our teachers know all because they went to college. Now that I’m in college, the only thing I’ve learned is that I really know nothing and that everything I’ve been taught deserves critical thought. For example, as children we took for fact that Christopher Columbus “sailed the ocean blue” and discovered the greatest country of all time. No one ever tells us that he killed, tortured, raped, took what wasn’t his, and committed mass genocide. We don’t learn about the realities of our history until we are taught about social issues in our sociology, communication, or women’s studies classes—all of which aren’t offered (generally) until college. So what about people who don’t get to go to college? Are they not worthy of learning about a history that wasn’t just written by wealthy white men? I’ll never forget the sudden realization that came over me when I first heard about the problems surrounding history education. I remember thinking, that’s why I hate history. I’m not a part of it. No one like me is represented.
            As far as privilege is concerned, though, I’ve got it pretty good. My parents are middle class, I’m white, I’m able-bodied, I’m fairly thin, I’m heterosexual. I can’t imagine trying to absorb knowledge in our society as a poor, black disabled lesbian. The fact is, people like this actually do exist, and where will they see their unique perspectives represented? I’ll tell you where: in gender studies, in feminist writing, in feminist standpoint theory, and in Jarratt’s writing. Works in this discipline are advocating for the silenced, and, sadly, these oppressed people are likely not going to be capable of accessing such valuable information.
            This reminds me of the Comstock laws that I learned about in my Women’s History (not regular History, I might add) class. It was the poor women who already had 8 children and an abusive husband who made $3 a month who couldn’t get access to information about birth control. While disseminating works like Jarratt’s isn’t illegal, it’s not reaching those who need it most. Maybe my comparison is a stretch, but I really don’t think so. In order for the disadvantaged to learn about their histories, they need accessible information. This means it needs to written in such a way that most people can understand. This is the only way certain groups will ever gain any power.

            As I mentioned above, there is a time and a place for challenging, jargonistic writing. Without it, Women’s Studies could not be an academic discipline. Through research and the official style of writing, this feminized, undervalued field of study has gained power. I just wonder, why is overcomplicating necessary to achieve power? Shouldn’t a field that aims to achieve equality for all people attempt to gain clout through enlightening all people, instead of only privileged college students? My frustration comes from the period in life in which I’ve become educated about such important issues, especially because I am a woman. Had I been introduced to feminism earlier in life, I could’ve been saved from a lot of self-hate, oppression from my peers, and the guilt of unknowingly being an oppressor in the past (and still today). It’s time that valuable information reaches younger, broader audiences.

The Official Style and Opinion Pieces Written as Fact, by Madison N.

The Official Style and Opinion Pieces Written as Fact

Barbara J. Fields is an African-American woman born in Charleston, South Carolina in the 1950s. She is currently a Professor of American History at Columbia University. Prior to becoming a professor, she first earned a BA from Harvard followed by a PhD from Yale. Among many other achievements and awards, Fields was the first African-American woman at Columbia to receive tenure.
Being a professor at a prestigious university, Fields is highly educated. I believe she writes in the Official Style because after several years as a student in the education system, topped with even more years as a professor, she is used to writing in this formal practice. It is also possible she writes this way to give off an authority she feels she has earned. She has a PhD and she might want to profess her wisdom and knowledge onto others. In some cases it does not seem right to have such a vast amount of education and write plainly, thus she does not.
A noteworthy aspect of her writing is that she writes in a passive voice; however not quite as passive as other official style pieces. She uses the pronouns “we,” “our” and “their” to discuss a group of people, but she never includes the word “I.” If she did include “I” it may take away from her piece because it puts emphasis on the notion that these are just her opinions. By leaving herself out of the writing, her thoughts and ideas have a quality of higher power. Her thoughts are delivered as fact rather than opinion, in other words, it simply enhances the authoritative and knowledgeable tone. 
It is evident Fields wants to discredit those whom support racial ideology because she states, “no one holding reputable academic credentials overtly adheres to the view that race is a physical fact.” This sentence should send off a red flag because she makes a very opinionative statement that can easily be seen as controversial. She basically states that those who disagree with her are not educated people. So, even though she keeps “I” out of the writing, as an African-American, she assumedly takes this topic personally. She was born in the south in the 1950s, for this reason, it is likely she has experienced racial discrimination in one form or another giving her writing bias. It is possible she wants to keep herself out of the writing because she wants to hide her bias as an African-American woman. First person might appear to extreme readers that Fields is bias because she is a part of a race that racial ideology negatively impacts prominently and not because she is specialized in this academic area.
Another way Fields utilizes the Official Style is through her lack of specificity. This is demonstrated in the phrase, “mediated by the social context within which the two come into contact.” This phrase has the air of Official Style because, well, it is rather confusing. It is not definitive because she does not state what the “two things” are within the sentence. Even in the previous sentence she never explicitly mentions, to my understanding, two obvious ideas, people or groups. If she replaced ambiguous phrases with exact information, clarity would be reached. However, the Official Style does not care about clarity and preciseness.
Similarly, Fields deliberately chooses her words carefully-- this can be seen in the sentence, “With a few well-publicized exceptions, no one holding reputable academic credentials overtly adheres to the view that race is a physical fact.” The words “holding,” “reputable,” “credentials,” “overtly” and “adheres” are thought-out word choices. She could have easily said, “A well educated person wouldn’t agree that race is a physical fact.” I believe she selected the words she did to illustrate that she is, in fact, an educated person, and she does not believe the notion of race being biological. Fields is discussing a not only serious matter, but a controversial one as well. I believe it is important to her to appear credible to her audiences. If she writes plainly, people might not accept what she is saying. But if she writes with great diction, more people might take her argument seriously. Audiences might read this and conclude that she is educated and well-versed; therefore, this piece of writing must be purposeful and accurate.  
In the phrase “this line of inquiry has yielded” she makes calculated word choices as well. The words “line of inquiry” are striking because I question what it even represents. What does she mean a “line”? She could have made the decision to state what was so questioning, but she did not. Fields also could have chosen the word “stop” or “given up” to reach a wider audience, but she did not. Again, I believe this is her way of sounding well-read in order to get her point about racial ideology across. 
These stylistic aspects may be praised by those in this particular academic field, but disliked in other activity systems. Opposing audiences, such as pro-racial ideologists, might view Fields’s wordiness as beating around the bush. Her work may be discredited because it is not clear and often difficult to follow. Students unfamiliar with this particular discipline may read her work and immediately view her as credible because they have been taught that the Official Style is a sign of credibility. Students may not understand the specifics of what Fields is discussing, but they walk away taking her view point as the only answer. On the other hand, students may view her piece as false because they notice the confusing sentences and get a sense she is attempting to hide a greater truth. People who have been discriminated against because of the idea of racial ideology might be passionate enough about the topic to be pleased with this work—no matter the level of confusion within Fields’s piece. All of these activity systems’ views pose implications because they judge the content based on stylistic choices or topic choice—not by the actual content, arguments or motives of Fields.
I believe Fields’s motives are to not only educate, but persuade others to view race differently. Her educational background paired with a list of honors and awards, suggests to me that her work is reliable and worthy of attention. Therefore, I do not determine her work to be dishonest or filled with idiocy. With that being said, she does have motives for writing this piece. She wants to persuade readers’ opinions on racial ideology-- otherwise she wouldn’t be challenging its notion. It also appears she wants to discredit those who disagree with her as seen in a previous example.
More generally, I think Fields’s piece helps raise questions on how the Official Style functions within an opinion piece. Fields writing is her opinion, whether it is widely accepted or not; however, she never utilizes the word “I.” I believe opinion writers as a whole avoid the first person because they want to present their work as fact. They want to persuade their readers to agree with them without blatantly presenting their work as only their point of view. Unless readers look closely, they might miss the authors’ true motives and agendas. The largest implication, in my opinion, that stems from the authors of these types of pieces is that they aren’t being honest with their readers. Their work may be riddled with opinion statements, but they are not presented that way and it gets confusing for readers—and these pieces are meant to be read. The largest implication that stems from readers is that no matter the activity system we are a part of, we often judge writing based on technique versus content. Passive voice, diction choice, and sentence structure are how we judge credible content. This is problematic because these are not always accurate ways to judge writing.
There are countless ways to interpret academic opinion pieces written as fact. It is important to note that not all of these pieces will result in the same analysis or conclusions. Each author will have their own agenda and purpose, but it necessary to question the possibilities of what they might be. It is also helpful to gain insight on the authors’ background to aid in determining their potential purpose(s).
- Madison N.

Technobabble: The Official Style in Science

          The official style is often criticized for being obtuse and unreadable. Richard Lanham, the man who first quantized and named the official style, was so disgusted with it that he waged a war against everything it stood for, even creating his own remedial “paramedic style” to be applied whenever possible. And while it is true that, to the majority of readers, the official style is frustrating if not completely useless, its elements have their place. As with many things in rhetoric, the practicality of the official style is not a black and white issue. One area in which the official style is both common and practical is among academic papers. Many of the official style strategies, while too cumbersome for every-day writing, actually help in the transmission of academic ideas.   
            Nuclear Physics B journal. While it is available online, it’s hidden behind a paywall of thirty-five dollars. This context is important to consider. Nothing exists in a vacuum, and what may appear absurd in one situation may be (and often is) perfectly reasonable in another. Context can also reveal clues as to the motivations of the writer. The exchange of ideas and information from writer to audience and the wider world always influences what’s being written, on some level. In the case of “Loop space,” the goal of its writers was, at least partially, to be published in Nuclear Physics B. The title of the journal alone lets the reader know what they’re in for. It is clearly by academics, for academics, within a highly specialized field which only a relative few people on Earth truly understand. In submitting to Nuclear Physics B, the authors open themselves and their work up to peer review and criticism. The need to appear official and authoritative is understandable. The issue of the paywall may also have influenced the decisions of the authors. Knowing, as they surely did, that their work would be published in a journal that requires a significant price to be accessed, it’s not difficult to believe that the authors would try their hardest to make their submission up to snuff. But were these the only reasons for the use of the official style? And how exactly did the authors apply the hallmarks of the style to their writing?
For the purposes of this critique, a document was chosen to represent certain elements of the official style. In this case, the document was an abstract from a paper entitled “Loop space representation of quantum general relativity.” The full paper was published in the February 1990 edition of the
            The abstract reads as follows:
“We define a new representation for quantum general relativity, in which exact solutions of the quantum constraints may be obtained.
The representation is constructed by means of a noncanonical graded Poisson algebra of classical observables, defined in terms of Ashtekar's new variables. The observables in this algebra are nonlocal and involve parallel transport around loops in a three-manifold Σ. The theory is quantized by constructing a linear representation of a deformation of this algebra. This representation is given in terms of an algebra of linear operators defined on a state space which consists of functionals of sets of loops in Σ. The construction is general and can be applied also to Yang-Mills theories.
The diffeomorphism constraint is defined in terms of a natural representation of the diffeomorphism group. The hamiltonian constraint, which contains the dynamics of quantum gravity, is constructed as a limit of a sequence of observables which incorporates a regularization prescription. We give the general solution of the diffeomorphism constraint in closed form. It is spanned by a countable basis which is in one-to-one correspondence with the diffeomorphism equivalence classes of multiple loops, which are a generalization of the link classes studied in knot theory. Then we explicitly construct, in closed form, a large space of solution of the entire set of constraints, including the hamiltonian constraint. These turn out to be classified by the ordinary knot and link classes of Σ.
The space of solutions that we find is a sector of the physical states space of nonperturbative quantum general relativity. The failure of perturbation theory is thus shown to be not relevant to the problem of the existence of a nontrivial physical state space in quantum gravity. The relationship between this new loop representation and the self-dual representation of Ashtekar is illuminated by means of a functional transform between states in the two representations. Questions of the completeness of the solution space, the meaning of the physical operators and the physical inner product, are discussed, but not, so far, resolved.”

At a glance, it’s an eyeful. It’s easy to become lost in only the first several sentences. Pushing through and actually perusing the paragraphs, several official style strategies leap out. Passive voice is used repeatedly: “solutions of the quantum constraints may be contained,” “The theory is quantized,” “The Hamiltonian constraint…is constructed.” Nothing in the universe does anything, it seems, but are only involved in things that happen. Latinate diction abounds (“quantized,” “regularization,” etc.), but most of all, the abstract is absolutely filled with jargon. “Quantum constraints,” “Noncanonical graded Poisson algebra,” “Ashtekar’s new variables,” “parallel transport,” “three-manifold Σ,” and all within the first three sentences. To an outsider it renders even a single sentence virtually unreadable, and to read it aloud would require speech therapy. Even the title of the paper, “Loop space representation of quantum general relativity,” is 70% jargon. The effect is a feeling of moving further away from reality the further one reads into the document. It climbs the ladder of abstraction with each sentence, until the (every-day) reader is left uncertain of whether they read anything at all. It wouldn’t be out of place in a bad Star Trek script that needed some technobabble padding.
            The obvious question here is, what’s the point? Not just in the jargon (although that seems to be the most offensive), but in any of the strategies present? Generally it could be said that, within the official style, passive voice is used to distance ones’ self from what is being written, to avoid any real responsibility. And while the passive voice is present within the abstract, that doesn’t seem to be its function. In a trend contrary to typical official style documents, the few places where passive voice is not used are where the authors do take responsibility: “We define a new representation for quantum general relativity,” says the opening sentence. Placed within the context of academia, this choice can be easily understood. It could be argued that half the point of publishing anything in a scientific journal is to claim credit for your discoveries. Whatever happened in this paper sounds like it was a lot of work; it’s understandable that the authors would want credit where it’s due.
            The Latinate diction, viewed in the context of an academic paper, can also be easily explained. After all, Latin was once the language of academia. Its spirit still flows through universities today, in the bloated papers of college kids everywhere. Latinate diction provides a sense of authority, something the authors likely strived for. And while it is present in the abstract, it isn’t necessarily obtrusive or unjustified. “Quantized” refers to the act of narrowing something down, from the general to the specific, a concept that applies directly to quantum physics.
            But can the jargon be excused? One of the goals of scientific work is to pursue knowledge for the sake of knowledge, and good scientific ethics demand that that knowledge be made available to all members of the public. What good is that if this knowledge is hidden behind jargonistic phrases like “nonperturbative quantum general relativity” that require a doctorate to understand? Combined with the steep paywall that prevents access to the full paper, it is easy to see a somewhat malevolent motivation behind the use of so much jargon. Scientific knowledge, arguably some of the most profound and important knowledge currently possessed by the human race, becomes a commodity, accessible only by a select few. A sort of classism arises, between those that understand the jargon and those that don’t. Knowledge becomes hidden, and the ethics of scientific study are tossed aside.
            It is easy to levy such criticisms against academic articles like this one. Nobody enjoys feeling like an outsider, especially if the Other is privy to the secret knowledge of the universe. Unreadability is one of the main assaults against the official style, and a valid one. But, again, context must be considered. What is unreadable to some is not unreadable to others. The truth is, papers like “Loop space representation of quantum general relativity” was not written for the masses. It seems to be aimed at an inner circle because that is exactly who it was written for. Never mind credibility and paywalls; quantum physics and general relativity are heady topics that necessitate specialists if humanity is to understand them at all. The use of jargon may exclude the majority of the public, but for those specialists it makes things much easier. It functions as short-hand, conveying ideas and concepts so complicated the only other way they could be fully expressed is through Einstein-level mathematics. The information is not being hidden, simply unboxed. It needs to start somewhere, and after the academic articles have been published and reviewed in journals like Nuclear Physics B, then the knowledge can be disseminated to the wider public through publications like New Scientist. This too requires some level of specialization: the ability to translate official style into common style, while still maintaining a coherent message. It all comes back to context.

            Too often, it seems, the official style is torn down. What few people realize is that it has its place. This applies to both critics and supporters. Certainly the average customer shouldn’t have to wade through reams of legalese in order to understand what they’re agreeing to when they sign up for iTunes, but the quantum physicist should be free to communicate in a language they understand in order to fully convey ideas. Richard Lanham seeks to eradicate the official style completely, but to do so would be a mistake. Like most things in life, the answer to “Is the official style useful?” is, “It depends.” The official style has its place, but is it always worth muddying the ethical waters? Before we throw it out completely, we should consider: Is there a better way?
                      -- Christian Velguth