Wednesday, October 22, 2014

The Official Style Battle of Journalism and Experimental Research


You may have glanced at the newspaper this morning, or a news app on your smart phone, and found that a new study discovered a shocking innovation that guarantees weight loss or that the food on your plate could potentially be deadly.  Media’s reports of scientific research often distort the reality of research conclusions, stirring vicious and ultimately meaningless debates.  Often, scientific research is jargon heavy and complicated, with many elements of what rhetoric scholar Richard A. Lanham refers to as “the official style” of prose language. In contrast, the field of journalism attempts to remove this official style from the explanation of research.  The problem is that the language used in the varying sources of this information leads to different interpretations of the same arguments.  In experimental research, the official style is a necessary component in establishing credibility by ensuring the accuracy of the description and explanation of the results of the studies.  The official style’s necessity in the field of experimental research has created a gap between society’s questions and the researchers’ ability to answer those questions; a gap that is weakly bridged by journalist media’s reporting on the research findings.  By analyzing articles from various sources involving the current understanding of “organic foods,” the parasitic relationship between experimental research articles and corresponding news columns plainly emerges and unveils a larger societal need for critical thinking. 
            Experimental research plays a large role in directing the patterns and progress of human behavior, but this role is often shadowed by the need for research evidence to be presented credibly and accurately to the professionals within the field.  When the public asks questions such as, “Is organic food better for me than real food?” researchers set out to find answers and have them published in dozens of scholarly and scientific journals.  However, the sources of the findings are so drenched in “the official style” that they become inaccessible to the average consumer.  For example, researchers at Stanford University conducted a meta-analysis of hundreds of organic food studies in 2012, published in the Annals of Internal Medicine.  The study, titled “Are Organic Foods Safer or Healthier than Conventional Alternatives? A Systematic Review” comes to no conclusive solution for the public’s undying curiosity.  The official style is used throughout the article to maintain accuracy and convey credibility, but its abundance makes deciphering the researchers’ conclusions essentially impossible.  As such, this sentence from the article riddles, “All estimates of differences in nutrient and contaminant levels in foods were highly heterogeneous except for the estimate for phosphorus; phosphorus levels were significantly higher than in conventional produce, although this difference is not clinically significant.”  The semicolon, multiple prepositional phrases and technical jargon are highly indicative of the official style.  Using the Flesch-Kincaid Reading Ease calculator, a tool designed to rate the ease with which one can read a piece, the reading ease level of this segment is measured at an 8.  Further, the “grade-level” assigned to this piece is an 18.5.  In 1993, The National Center for Educational Statistics found that the average U.S. adult reads at the 7th grade level.  Comparing these grade levels shows that the average American could not successfully comprehend and interpret the findings of the study.  Still, it was important that the findings of the study be presented with the official style in order to uphold the self-correcting nature of scientific research. This idea outlines the necessity for research to be replicable by other researchers to create reliable consistency of the results.  Because of this motive, the technical jargon used in the explanation of the conclusions is intended for peers in the field and motivated by the need to be precisely accurate, down to the word choice.  We saw in the above quote from the article that the results could be perceived as apparently contradicting to the average reader: “phosphorus levels were significantly higher than in conventional produce, although this difference is not clinically significant.”  If one does not know the difference between significance and clinical significance, something that is established through statistical data analysis, the results could be deemed incomprehensible.  While the official style is inherently necessary in maintaining the scientific expectations of publishing research, its resulting inaccessibility to the public leads to a reliance on the more abundant and reachable information provided by news articles.   
            Relying on a media source to direct our behavior may not be the best decision, however it is the purpose of such mediums to make scientific discoveries and their societal implications available to the public.  The public has more physical access to news articles because their various sources eliminate the need for a subscription to a journal, such as is needed for experimental research.  Readers are more likely to understand the language of journalists, which may lead them to trust the information that is more clearly stated.  In response to the published findings by Stanford University on the status of perceptions of organic foods, journalist Michelle Brandt published a column in the Stanford Medicine News Center titled, “Little Evidence of Health Benefits from Organic Foods, Study Finds.” While the article provided a detailed summary of the research study, it received a reading ease score of 35, which is much higher than the research article and several ‘grade levels’ lower.  The following sentence received a high school-aged grade level, much closer to the reading abilities of the average American: “You figure you’ve just made the healthier decision by choosing the organic product — but new findings from Stanford University cast some doubt on your thinking.”  This inviting narrative, featuring a more direct voice than the passive voice that is characteristic of the official style, elicits more publicity by framing the results of the study in this way as opposed to detailing the more comprehensive results of a “systematic review.”  By removing the official style and attempting to explain and describe the results of research without the technical jargon, journalists often lose the accuracy provided by scientific journals.
            Another article from The Huffington Post provides further evidence that the public holds distorted views of the article as a result of multiple interpretations from multiple different news sources. The article’s author, Jonny Bowden argues, “The media reporting of a new Stanford study purporting to show that organic food has no substantial benefit over conventionally grown food is a wonderful example of how to reduce a complex issue into a moronic sound bite. Google the study and you'll find at least a dozen entries beginning with ‘Organic Food No Better for You.’  The study -- or rather, the media reporting on it -- has generated quite a bit of buzz.”  By reducing the official style language used in the original article to a static claim, not only do the true results of the study become distorted and misreported, they also spread like wildfire due to their increased accessibility.  The first thing a reader sees when viewing any sort of article is the headline.  The gap in representations of the same information is salient in the two sources’ differing headlines.  The Stanford researchers’ article is titled, “Are Organic Foods Safer or Healthier than Conventional Alternatives? A Systematic Review” while Brandt’s article reworded and summarized her interpretation of the results as “Little Evidence of Health Benefits from Organic Foods, Study Finds.” The systematic, experimental review, which addresses both sides of the controversy over organic foods, will never be explored by the crowds of readers exposed only to the news article that successfully and clearly answered their original question, though not entirely accurately. 
            The sphere of journalism relies on the gap between the presentation of experimental research results and the public’s understanding of those results to insert less objective opinions and understandings of the data into the published literature, fueling debates such as the one revolving around organic foods.  This is achieved by reducing the official style that is abundant in experimental research articles.  Unfortunately, the issue that arises from this relationship is the public’s acceptance of inaccurate information.  In this case, the official style becomes a hurdle to understanding and even receiving the true results of scientific research.  The question then becomes, should we compromise the accuracy and credibility of experimental research to increase the accessibility of real results?  Is it possible to encourage American readers, consumers and scholars to think critically about the information they are exposed to and create resources to facilitate understanding of difficult literature?  This proposition could lead us down a path of educational and societal improvement not limited to scholarly spheres of human activity.     
-Alayna Stein    

Tuesday, October 21, 2014

Screenwriting in Academia Overcompensates with Official Style


While the sphere that I wanted to analyze was screenwriting, in particular, I ended up finding an academic, scholarly article about screenwriting instead. I analyzed a small portion of Virginia Pitt’s Writing from the body: Kinesthetics and entrainment in collaborative screenwriting. Already, within the title we see the official style rear its head through the dreaded two-part title. I could already assume that the article had copious amounts of official style. After several minutes of trying to read through the article I decided to focus on several of the more official paragraphs rather than the piece as a whole. Pitts is an established screenwriter and after the experience of writing her script for the 2010 short film Beat she decided to document her latest revelations in this academic article. The article is intended for the academic world and in academia it is expected that scholars write in the official style, but it would much too easy to say that this is the only reason Pitts would choose to use the official style so excessively. I argue that the underlying reason Pitts engages in so much official style is to overcompensate for the natural tendency for scripts to be full of plain language. Scripts are extremely easy to read and to understand, because the majority of them are dialogue, a colloquial conversation. They must be easily digested in order for audiences who are watching to understand the plot and the characters. Because of this, when Pitts analyzes her own screenwriting techniques, she exaggerates her use of official style to overcompensate for the simplicity of the conversational language of scripts. If she had written her scholarly article in similar language as her script was written in, it would have appeared as if she hadn’t given enough critical thought to her thesis.

Take this sentence for example: “Having experienced the traditional process of writing in a solitary environment, my second research question asked how a more collaborative form of film development might open out possibilities as a result of interacting with the creative energies of others, in this case performers and a choreographer.” This is an official way of saying, “My second research question asks how a typical script might change if the performers were involved.” I cut down the sentence from 37 words to 16 words. Surely, it would have been easier for Pitts to use my sentence rather than her own, but these two sentences are not identical in their word choice, nor their meaning. The shorter choppier sentence I wrote has an entirely different connotation than Pitts’s sentence. Mine seems brief, choppy, and altogether not thought out. Meanwhile when Pitts uses the official style in her writing it exemplifies her passion for her subject, the knowledge and time she has put into the article, and also, it demonstrates her ability as a writer to construct complex sentences with seeming ease. All of these things lend themselves to establishing her credibility as a writer.

Many times when writers choose to use the official style it is used for deception or lending to credibility, but I argue Pitts tends to use it to contrast the plain language found in most scripts. Apart from stage direction and setting, scripts are primarily dialogue which means characters speak in an easily understandable plain way. Well this doesn’t help much when Pitts is trying to write a scholarly article so she overcompensates for the plain nature of scripts. In the example sentence above she has an 11 word participial phrase to start the sentence. The core meaning of the sentence is the same even if she just completely deleted that. Next, look at her diction, ignoring the participial phrase, “collaborative”, “film development”, “creative energies”. None of these terms or phrases were necessary to the meaning of that sentence. Pitts uses this elevated language in her research analysis to distance herself from the script itself. If a character talked like this in a movie or TV show the audience would possibly have troubles keeping up.

I understand that in academia it is expected that writers of scholarly articles write in official style but Pitts is writing at a reading ease level of 23, a level that not many excerpts have been able to match. In her article Pitts mentions and points to Bakhtin as an influence on the way she views language and writing. Bakhtin is a master of the official style in his excerpt about utterances. The level of complexity that Pitts obtains begs for an ulterior motive other than academic writing. Pitt’s article focuses around a plain language script and a personal learning experience she had, which makes the article read like a narrative at times. She must prove to her fellow scholars that researching something so colloquial as a script can be considered academic, and that is why she uses official language so excessively. Then to avoid being considered a narrative piece Pitts incorporates passive language to distance herself from the piece.

Considering my own experiences while reading this article, I wonder if Pitts took her language to an extreme or if she was required to do so. Certainly, I wasn't within the sphere that Pitts envisioned for her audience but this raises the question of, is it practical to write in this way when the majority of the audience the speaker is writing to refuses to read past the second paragraph out of sheer boredom. It restricts the audience and it restricts its usefulness, and screenwriting becomes less personable of a profession. Or, rather, has Pitts outsmarted my own analysis completely. It would be useful to note that Pitts audience may not have been, as I assumed, all screenwriters. True, it would benefit screenwriters to engage in the debate that Pitts outlines by taking the actors into account whilst writing a script, but because of the academic nature of this piece perhaps it is intended solely for the academic kind interested in this type of research. Within the article, Pitts analyzes language like a linguist does, she analyzes body movements like a psychologist does, she analyzes dialogue like a sociologist does. The initial assessment that Pitts uses the official style to distance herself from screenwriting can be considered half right and half wrong. Certainly, her article reads nothing like a script, but Pitts may not be intentionally distancing herself from the script for the sake of being taken seriously, but rather her use of the official style, which demonstrates her abundance of knowledge across multiple schools of learning, distances herself from the one dimensional aspect of solely being a writer of scripts.
-Matthew Leitner


"Girl Talk" in the Official Style

The third wave of feminism is alive and active in the United States, and this time, supporters are determined to ensure that a fourth wave won’t be necessary. Thousands of people have become advocates as the new wave turns heads and stirs up controversy. As was the case in the first and second waves in the late 1800s and 1960s, scholars have hopped on board and begun stringing together feminist texts chalk full of the official style. Use of the official style is controversial in itself, as it tends to be riddled with high-falutin language and twisted, brain-warping sentence structures, making it nearly impossible for the average reader to interpret. Since advocates, in any context, intend to draw attention to a particular issue and persuade a broad population to join the movement, it seems counter-productive to make use of the official style within the sphere of feminist advocacy. However, plain language TED Talks alone, full of emotional appeal but lacking adequate information about the subject, won’t cut it. Could there be a place for the official style in feminist advocacy?
            Simply put, feminism is a big issue. It involves first-world and third-world nations, gender equality, understanding and acceptance of LGBT individuals, and issues of racism, and it weaves between disciplines with ease. It is this complexity that requires the work of scholars to delve into every aspect of feminism. Although scholars write about a wide variety of subjects, we can see parallels within their work. Notable journalist and feminist scholar Susan Faludi, in her book “Backlash: The Undeclared War Against Women,” took on the issue of male superiority vs. female inferiority, writing,
“When an attack on home soil causes cultural paroxysms that have nothing to do with the attack, when we respond to real threats to our nation by distrusting ourselves with imagined threats to femininity and family life, when we invest our leaders with a cartoon masculinity and require of them bluster in lieu of a capacity for rational calculation, and when we blame our frailty in 'fifth column' feminists - in short, when we base our security on a mythical male strength that can only increase itself against a mythical female weakness - we should know that we are exhibiting the symptoms of a lethal, albeit curable, cultural affliction (p. 295).”
This excerpt is one sentence. Just one. It uses several official style strategies, including excessive prepositional phrase strings, difficult vocabulary, and long, complex sentences (or sentence, since there’s only one). Despite the average grade level of 37.6 and Flesch-Kincaid Reading Ease of -40.1, Faludi does, for the most point, avoid many of the impassive and “overly polite” strategies, like “is” verbs and euphemisms, to really attack the issue at hand, making this sentence a potentially effective mode of advocacy.
            Judith Ann Perez, however, in her work on Latina feminism, uses more blatant official style strategies, although the grade level is significantly lower at 19.2, most likely due to the shorter sentence lengths.
“Latina feminism was born out of a civil rights initiative that addressed structural inequalities and is a modified Latino version of the women's liberation movement. The pioneer women's movement failed Latinas because it did not address the many differences, compared with White middle-class women, that inform a pan-ethnic Latina consciousness. Since the 1960s and 1970s, the feminist movement has infrequently recognized internal differences among women of color, including Latinas. Because Latinas can be of any race, it is no easy task to achieve an inclusive pan-ethnic Latina consciousness that can thrive within a general feminist dialectic.”
Perez uses “is” verbs, feminist jargon, and nominalization, in addition to prepositional phrases, difficult vocabulary, and complex sentences that mirror strategies in Faludi’s piece, although, content wise, they have little in common. These strategies are displayed in a vast variety of feminist texts, including L. Vogel’s “Debating Difference: Feminism, Pregnancy, and the Workplace,” RW Connell’s “Gender and Power: Society, the person and sexual politics,” and even many of second wave feminist Simone de Beauvoir’s works.
            These strategies aren’t, however, seen in more commonplace acts of feminist advocacy. Emma Watson’s address to the U.N. averaged a grade level of 6.3, and author Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s TED Talk came out to a 6.9. When analyzing the content of these and several other well-known speeches on feminism, there appears to be little to no official style present, favoring instead plain and creative styles. Of course, this isn’t exactly surprising. An address to the general public of the country or world should be written at roughly the average reading level in order to reach the masses. Since, in America, the average reading grade level is seven, Watson and Adichie’s speeches fit perfectly. But, where does that leave Faludi, Perez, and other feminist scholars? Compared to these mainstream speeches, it might appear that their in-depth, official analyses have no place in the sphere of feminist advocacy.
            Advocacy aims to reach as many people as possible in as many modes of communication as needed to achieve that goal. That means men, women, millennials, baby boomers, students, working-class citizens, and, yes, scholars. Academics tend to communicate with higher vocabulary and more complex sentence structure than “lay people.” Even the most accomplished of scholars have more to learn, and in order for the various realms of feminism to reach scholars, it almost certainly needs to be delivered not by typical activists, but by other scholars. However, the separation between scholars and activists could be problematic. Regardless of subgenre, the root of feminism is equality. By that logic, it would make sense to treat all people as equals in terms of spreading the ideas of feminism instead of grouping them as “academics” or “non-academics.” With this in mind, it is still difficult to say that the official style should be abolished in feminist advocacy.
            To an average American, scholarly feminist texts may seem too convoluted to ever be effective. But, upon deeper analysis, it is difficult to deny that more information appears to be given in scholarly articles than in widespread speeches. Yes, some of the official style is excessive and unnecessary, and yes, there is certainly a larger time commitment involved when it comes to feminist academia than a TED Talk. However, many of those prepositional phrases, coordinations, relative clauses, and difficult diction are actually accomplishing something. These techniques exist for the purpose of further clarification and providing more information. Faludi’s epic, grade 37 sentence provides readers with a variety of scenarios that are detrimental to the feminist movement, information that is valuable if society is to move forward. Perez uses the official style to explain improvements that can be made to feminist advocacy in order to include the elusive Latina race. Information is knowledge, and knowledge is power. The official style’s place in feminist advocacy is providing as much knowledge as possible, and while knowledge can obviously be passed via other writing styles, none use language strategies as potently as the official style to pack in lots and lots of knowledge. Removing all that knowledge from advocacy would be completely ineffective.

            Feminism is big, not only it’s content, but also it’s audience. No one person can master it all, which means that there is no perfect advocate, whether activist or scholar. For this reason, the official style does have a place in feminist advocacy. The question is, how large of place does it have? Is there a way to achieve a “happy medium,” utilizing the emotional, passion-inducing techniques of mainstream activists along with the informational aspect of official style strategies? Generalized speeches are a great place for the average citizen to begin to delve into the world of feminism, but they can’t be expected to go straight from there to scholarly articles. By employing, but not overindulging, the official style, this third wave of feminism will go down in history as the one that changed everything.

By Elena Montanye

Monday, October 20, 2014

The Official style Unhooked

                 Official style creates unnecessary complexity and can warp and mutate writing, but at the same time it can inform and intrigue in a professional way. Fishing is such an informal interest; it simply requires a fishing pole, some line, and bait, but if this is the case, why do authors of fishing articles use the complex official style? In my research I noticed two major article types that involved official style. Authors wrote about strategies and techniques professional anglers use to catch more fish. These articles usually contain new challenging information and difficult vocabulary. The other type of article describes the author’s stories and experiences. These articles usually contain creative, but in certain cases unclear, word choice. Although fishing articles do contain some official language it does not contain a lot and even when used it rarely affects the article. With that being said, sometimes they incidentally isolate new fishermen who read them.
                Authors of the informational fishing articles are usually professionals so the information and vocabulary can be challenging for an angler who has just started. As a reader I appreciate fishing articles written by professional anglers because it means the information is credible, but at the same time it can be difficult to understand the techniques described or the information that is talked about. A reader must understand a professional angler is a very specialized position, so certain points in an article are going to seem foreign to even experienced anglers. The difference in fishing knowledge between a professional and an experienced angler is similar to a professors’ knowledge compared to a students’. Familiarity with fishing doesn’t mean you will understand the very difficult and scientific information some articles present. I believe the articles are meant to be highly informational, and directed towards an audience that has the knowledge and equipment to take advantage of the information given. It is still a shame, even though I feel it is incidental, that articles written like this do create a skill level hierarchy. It keeps the beginners on the bottom and the experts on the top.
There’s the seiche effect, which is current that is caused by the settling out of water after a prolonged blow in one direction, or by seismic, atmospheric or lunar effect. A “reverse current” is caused by strong winds blowing in the opposite direction of the natural flow through a river or reservoir, and if it’s prolonged, the backside of structures may turn on with active muskies.            
This is a quote from a highly challenging and informational fishing article. I believe this is official style due to the difficult vocabulary and long complex sentences.  The quote above has thirty four words per sentence and is littered with prepositions, is- verbs, and difficult vocabulary. Although the quote above uses official style, I still believe the main goal of the article is to inform. This article style does create a knowledge based hierarchy but that’s not the intention of the article. Overall my original thoughts about official style being used as a power trip is not the intention or purpose of fishing articles but can sometimes seem that way because it is such a specialized sport.                              
                An important aspect of fishing is being able to share your stories and experiences with others who share your same passion and emotion for the sport.  This is a good way for an author to bond with experienced anglers/readers and attract new readers/anglers. Authors also write these articles to increase the membership and the income of their group. Although money and membership is a motive, I believe more importantly is the bond anglers share through their unique stories which is a very important aspect of being an angler. It forms a connection between anglers and it maintains the sport of fishing by keeping anglers interested as well as attracting new people to join.
It had been four hours since we had a sniff from a musky, and we were baked from the afternoon sun. Finally … a little relief, as the sun had settled low enough on the horizon     to cool the air and increase the shadows. The water — which only a few hours before appeared clear—now was black and spooky. Magic time had begun.
The quote contains more creative writing than official style yet some word choices especially the verbs and adjectives are misleading, but intriguing as well, which I believe is the purpose of the article. The author who wrote this passage was telling a story about one of his fishing experiences. You can tell the descriptive and creative writing could easily grab a readers’ attention. Designed to excite readers and interest them in the sport of fishing, I believe this quote is a creatively written anecdote in the article. Although written stories promote membership which involves money, the main purpose of official language in these articles is to be able to connect with people who share the same fishing interests as you. Similar to the informational article, anglers who haven’t had experiences can sometimes feel isolated at the bottom of the food chain.
                Official style is rare in fishing articles but when it is used it can have both good and bad effects. In my research I found two different article types that used official language both for different reasons. The first article was informational, which due to the complex sentences and difficult vocabulary I thought it was official style. Although these articles are very informational and credible I believe it does incidentally set up this skill based hierarchy. The second article type was authors sharing fishing stories and strategies. Although I do believe some articles use official style to promote membership or products most of the time I believe it’s the fishermen connecting and bonding with each other. Fishing articles contain little hints of official style, in these articles official style can have positive and negative effects, but for the most part it doesn’t affect the article at all.

-Sam Schneider

Official Style in the University's English Department


The official style, the ace the bureaucrats play when looking to confuse the innocent laypeople and the tricky, inaccessible language of the “Terms and Conditions” portion of a simple Internet exchange, oftentimes (and ever more often), creeps its way into daily life. Even academics, who typically pride themselves on excellent grasp of language, cannot apparently resist the temptations of the official style. The statement on the English-Literature homepage (access here) acts as a description for the department, a sort of “what we do here” explanation designed to entice prospective students to the program. Because the intended sphere is that of students or prospective students, one would assume the language used would be vibrant, exciting, but most essentially, easily accessible. But in this respect the statement falls short.
With the casual use of practices like noun substitutes, prepositional phrases, coordination, absolute phrases, and subordination the official style in the statement is easily tangible. Though it may at first seem to be merely an accidental slip into passive voice, it is deliberate and occurs in the most persuasive passages of the statement, for example, “In addition to helping students cultivate aesthetic sensibilities and multiply their reading pleasures….” This is a fantastically over-worded phrase that seeks to prove to the reader that the English-Literature major is both a sophisticated and a relevant area of study, and slips in a prepositional phrase for good measure. The official style is used in the various passages to foster both a sense of exclusion as well as to beckon in interested parties. Using the official style in writing gives the voice of the piece a certain tone, one of a stuffy scholar imparting wisdom to a child. In this manner, the piece lords over the laypeople that do not know how to manipulate language in the same manner as the scholar. The use of official style puts the passages on a pedestal, a subtle impression of the famous academic ivory tower that academics climb in order to turn their noses down on the less educated. This gives their intended audience a tangible example to grasp on to, something to strive for. But between the statement’s more official passages, plain speech is used in order to foster a sense of camaraderie, in order to ensure that a major in the English department seems achievable. That camaraderie is only used, however, so that the official style can severe it in the next sentence, to remind the reader that their choice of major requires skills they do not possess, that the ivory tower is not something that they have access to yet.
When evaluated with the readability scale, the average grade level is nearly seventeen (the reading level of a college graduate), a four-grade difference from the freshman or high school seniors that makes up the largest body of their targeted audience. The statement’s genre is that of informal, communicative writing; its purpose to inform students about the Literature program offered at UW-L. This is a genre that is not unique to the statement on the university website, rather, it is the genre that is used by several other school’s Literature departments’ statement. When looking to compare the statements from the websites of the University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire (access here) and the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee (access here), it is clear that UW-L’s statement is not on par with its competitors. UW-EC and UW-M’s statements are both much shorter, with much less official style. In this statement, clarity and easy accessibility are favored above sounding advanced. Why, then, does UW-L’s statement favor the official style over plain, to-the-point speech?
The adopted ivory tower speech/official style stems directly from the insecurity that most humanities departments are feeling in the age where a preference on the sciences is undisguised. As the number of undergraduates who are picking English as their majors continues to be ever fewer in number, the desperation of the already nervous department feels only increases. The result is the statement on the Literature department’s homepage. The use of the official style is, I believe, a sort of defense mechanism by the department to prove their relevancy and worth in an age that places little value on the written word. But their efforts, unfortunately, largely fall short, as most are driven away from the inaccessible language, rather than enticed into looking further into what UW-L could offer them.
            While the authors of this piece may walk away from this statement satisfied, sure that they have lured prospective university students away from other programs and universities, the students that are exposed to the statement are less than impressed. After viewing a handful of students’ distaste for this statement in a previous class, I believe the general atmosphere was one of bewilderment that UW-L’s Literature program beat out all the other programs they considered before deciding on a school to attend. While those in the department, as well as the students, can attest to the fact that UW-L’s English program is highly commendable, this is not conveyed through the statement on the website. However, while most would agree that the statement is highly problematic, it is not beyond the realm of assistance. Adopting aspects of plain, direct speech would serve this statement well, while still conveying the overall message: that an English degree can take you anywhere you want to go.
To conclude, the official style is used to both condescend its audience as well as beckon the students closer, in a very odd hybrid style of writing that shifts voice dramatically several times throughout the piece. In one sentence, the scholar lords from his ivory tower, but in the next offers a hand with which to guide the student along and forward. The use of official style unfortunately does not succeed in persuading its readers to pursue a major in English, and maybe perhaps even discourages them from looking further into UW-L. But though the official style is decidedly out of place in this work, the statement is not beyond the realm of redemption. 
Taylor Parrish, English 313, 20 October 2014

The Official Style: School District Application

Communication occurs on a near constant basis, with varying methods of delivery and interpretation. As society evolves to incorporate endless technological advancement it becomes increasingly important to focus on how information is delivered from person to person. Therefore, it is important to question how people relate to each other when everybody communicates in their own unique way. In order to provide a sense of specific understanding communication occurs following the format offered by the Official Style. The Official Style is a precise writing strategy aimed at following specific rules. It is used in many spheres of human activity, however focus will be set on school district environments to unpack how this style of writing is used in differing ways to portray a demeanor of professional and articulate nature in written materials.
            How can the utilization of various writing strategies influence the interpretation of written materials, specifically in a school district setting? The Official Style is very important because it follows a precise strategic model to portray a specific image about written works. By researching the differences in language that surround plain and official writing, it becomes obvious that the rhetoric used in the Official Style is effective for this specific sphere. School districts are predominantly federally and state funded academic institutions aimed at promoting and achieving high standards of student success. This means that image is a very important aspect to maintain, which implores the integration of the Official Style in a steadfast effort to ensure a positive and professional public image.
            The writing techniques used in the school district sphere of human activity follow the Official Style format to highlight stylistic strategies in a variety of ways. School psychologists often discuss various student related activities by writing in the Official Style. An article published by School Psychology Review titled, “A Randomized Evaluation of the Safe and Civil Schools Model for Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports at Elementary Schools in a Large Urban School District” attempts to convey important behavior issues commonly found in the classroom. However, the article does a poor job of helping people understanding the topic because of its immense length and overall complexity. By using the Official Style a limited number of people are able to successfully decipher and accurately interpret the meaning within the text. While this allows jargon and descriptive terms to be used at careless extremes for the benefit of individuals engrossed in a specific sphere, it also prevents the wide majority of the general public from being able to understand or interpret the information.
            The school district sphere of human activity encompasses a broad spectrum of written materials, however most information that is written within the sphere follows a specific format modeled after the Official Style. Research revealed that school psychologists, counselors, and administration are common perpetrators of the Official Style as written material is at or above the fifteenth grade level. While this useful tactic for maintains a status of superiority, people outside the sphere are unable to understand the depth of specific discussions. For example the sentence fragment from Ward and Gersten that states, “The term positive behavior supports referred generically to behavioral strategies that incorporated fundamental characteristics such as stating expectations for behavior in a positive manner, teaching those expectations overtly, using quantitative data to make decisions, and monitoring and measuring the effectiveness of implementation” will not be successfully interpreted by many people in various spheres of human activity. The components that determine the text is part of the Official Style can be identified in a variety of ways that come together to create a descriptive and thorough composition.
            This is an important issue to discuss because interpretation of text becomes increasingly difficult as the reading level increases; therefore the ability to interpret written works demands that the reader has attained a satisfactory reading level. The aforementioned text is uses absolute phrase to increasing the amount of information discussed by creating unnecessary wordiness. Absolute phrase is often used in the school district environment to entwine two separate thoughts into a singular and more complex idea. As the sentence reveals, the form of verbs could be altered to create multiple sentences that are simpler in structure. The use of absolute phrase encourages the creation of complex and lengthy sentences because content and significance merge to identify unified and specific themes. As themes become explored the writer’s immersion into the sphere increases, causing the style of writing within the sphere to revamp itself to follow a specific and choreographed model set at identifying elements within the sphere.
            While this may not appear to be an issue of significant importance, it is crucial to mention because written works support a specific agenda. While the intention of materials within any sphere is to provide information, often times the subject of the issues are unable to interpret the information for themselves. A hierarchy becomes established in the face of increasing understanding surrounding the multiple facets of communication, as each channel becomes reflective of one’s own status within the system of communication. In order to ensure accurate understanding of written works immersion into any sphere of activity is absolutely necessary because the way information is delivered demands that people remain unique individuals. This is particularly true in the school district setting because information is interpreted by many individuals and for a wide variety of purposes. Therefore, the Official Style has to be used to create thorough and complex documents aimed at providing a professional and complex demeanor.
            Although the Official Style of writing has a broad spectrum of application in the school district sphere of activity, the intentions and delivery of information is not necessarily aided by such a complex and difficult writing style. While it is necessary for institutions of education to maintain high standards of public image, is it also necessary to enable to greatest portion of society to be able to accurately understand the function and policy decisions that are conveyed in written materials? Interpretation of material is difficult for individuals that are not exposed to high standards of writing, which may make them less able to understand information that is being discussed. The Official Style belongs in this sphere of human activity, however there is also a need to convey information in a more normative and simplistic fashion for the general public as well.

-
Jacob Akin