Friday, April 17, 2015

How Plain Style Prevails in the Internet World



In comparison to official style, plain style illustrates a rather simple and more understandable way to convey information, which unarguably helps reach a larger audience. However, to discuss its effectiveness justly, we need to examine plain style from its textual and contextual aspects thoroughly. Therefore, I chose the article “The First Step to Building a Brand Called You” on the Forbes website. It is an article that offers suggestions for employees to build their personal brands in order to attain more confidence in themselves and to achieve career success. The contributor of this article is The Muse, a platform that provides job opportunities and expert advice to nationwide readers. In this sense, the source of the article has certain credibility. It uses a plain style for readers to understand The Muse’s ideas better; at the same time, I think it also loses its effectiveness in conveying the message because of its oversimplification and reduction of the complexity of building up people’s personal brands. The language style makes the content seem simple or easy, when in fact it is complicated.

The whole article is comparatively short—only two pages and the bold font for the subtitles and the usage of ballpoints contribute to a friendly, easy environment for mass audience to read, especially for busy readers. Now I will excerpt the four steps to build one’s personal brand in his/her career as my illustration of its usage of plain style.

1. Determine Your Emotional Appeal

For starters, think broadly about your personality and how it affects the experience someone will have with you. Are you insanely organized? Do people love working with you for your killer sense of humor?

Make a list of words that best describe these features of your personality. These words are known as emotional modifiers. Hint: They can be as simple as Disney’s “fun.”

2. Determine Your Description

Your next step is coming up with a descriptive modifier that brings clarity to the emotional modifier, identifying what or who your brand is for. In Disney’s case, it’s “family.” In Nike’s mantra, “authentic athletic performance,” “authentic” is the emotional appeal, while “athletic” tells you what the brand is for. As an individual, yours might be an industry (“healthcare” or “education”), or it might be a tangible skill (“creative” or “strategic”).

3. Determine Your Function

Lastly, write down what, exactly, you do (or will do). It might be something that directly relates to your career: writing, graphic design, or financial planning, for example. Or, it might be something more broad, like Disney’s “entertainment.” Are you a manager, a creator, an organizer? A connector of people?”

4. Pull It All Together

Finally, look at your three lists of words, and see how you can combine them into a short sentence or phrase—no more than five words. Your brand mantra should communicate clearly who you are, it should be simple and memorable, and it should feel inspiring to you. You might be a “dependable, strategic planner” or “a creative professional connector.” Or, your mantra might be something like, “motivating others to do their best.”

As we can observe from the above, these four steps are well organized in four paragraphs with a larger bold font. These details definitely create an easy reading opportunity for the people who want to grasp the main points at first sight and then have the interest to keep reading. Putting the form aside, let’s look at the content. According to Readability-Score, the four little paragraphs’ flesch-kincaid reading ease is 60, the average grade is 9.4, and words per sentence is 12.2. Its reading ease is quite high and its reading average grade level is low, so that it is easy and understandable for most of the readers. Looking through Step 1 to Step 4, we can discover that the article contributor makes his arguments straight and to the point at the beginning of each paragraph and uses logical words like “for starters,” “your next step,” “lastly,” and “finally” to link each paragraph. He also uses a very conversational tone and adopts the second person point of view in telling the audiences what to do and how to do it. For instance, the writer uses some declarative sentences to make the whole article sound very conversational and daily, like “for starters, think broadly about...” The usage of second person point of view like “look at your three lists of words, and...” makes the article sound more casual, just like you are giving advice to your friends. The usage of these techniques makes the article familiar to the readers and lets them become more than willing to follow and take the advice.

The writer also applies other plain style strategies to make his article more acceptable for the readers. Parallelism is shown in the very beginning sentence in these four steps, putting these equally important suggestions into similar grammatical structure. It helps the readers find the main information immediately and understand it without any difficulties. Also, the usage of Exemplum contributes to the construction of plain style in the article. Although the examples are quite short, they are already what we are familiar with (Disney’s and Nike’s) and are added behind every statement in each step to deepen the reader's’ understanding of how to build their personal brand through these examples.

Knowing the plain style strategies that the writer uses in the article, we also need to know the contextual meaning of why he chose to write like that. As I’ve stated in the intro paragraph, the aim of this article is to help more employees to find out what personalities they have and combine them with their own working positions in order to create more passion, energy, and success in their career. Therefore, the language use should be written in a comparatively plain way, since not every employee has a very high educational level. The Harvard, Yale graduates after all are only a very small proportion in American work force. Thus, it is considerably necessary and important for the writer to use a plainer and easier style to reach more ordinary people who are still confused about their future. However, in my opinion, though this article adopts plain style and is indeed very easy to read and understand, it is not as effective as it should be. Since it is written by a credible platform and posted on Forbes website and since the content is actually more complicated than it appears, it should combine with a little official style to make it more professional and credible.

In my opinion, this article oversimplifies and reduces the complexity of building one’s personal brand and achieving career success. It simply tells the readers that just by combining your emotional appeal, your description and function, and by memorizing your “mantra,” you can build your personal brand. But is that really all it takes? What effect will the “mantra” have, and will it be effective and credible? Or is it just a psychological implication that we can remind ourselves every day? We don’t know, because the article doesn’t tell us. To me, I just take it as a piece of reading entertainment, because it doesn’t tell me how effective the “mantra” will be and to what degree can I trust it.

Nowadays, using plain style in business (and also other areas) articles becomes a new trend and convention. As we are embracing a FMCG (fast-moving consumer goods) era, people have a large demand of consuming novel things, and hope the information and technology can be updated as fast as possible. People have less and less patience in waiting. Thus, articles online (no matter in what area) are written in an increasingly plain way in order to attract the readers’ attention. Many writers or contributors make the message appear simple, even though it should be more complicated. While the use of plain style attracts a large group of audience, it can also result in people thinking that something might be too easy or not require a lot of effort when in actuality it might take a lot of work.      

While at the same time, we should consider the intention of writing this article. Forbes is a professional business website, and it publish its magazines twice a month, which indeed needs a lot of new information and articles to fill in the vacancies in its website in order to provide readers with freshness and to keep its activeness. The topic “building up your personal brand” is indeed a hot issue in the modern workplace, but the oversimplification and reduction of its actual practicability and operability make its content questionable. Furthermore, Forbes’ speed of updating posts is striking: thirteen posts are created within one hour on its website when I randomly look through its homepage. These phenomenons inevitably lead us to consider its intention. By scratching these ideas in a quite general way, it seems that Forbes is just generating this content only to meet the readers’ expectation of solving problems easily. In my opinion, though people have the need of receiving information fast and of reading plain text, the writer and the website should still have the responsibility to ensure the effectiveness and credibility through using their language. The writer can use a little bit of official and professional style and add more details of its effectiveness in what kind of situation and to what kind of profession. In this way, it can at least make sure that the article won’t mislead the vast audience that the way to build up personal brand and the benefits it will bring are as easy as it tells in the content.

Lingyuan Xiong


Jeremy Clarkson, CNN, and the Plain Style

On March 25, 2015, CNN published an article online addressing the current controversy between Jeremy Clarkson and the BBC.  Clarkson was the host of the incredibly popular show, “Top Gear”.  Clarkson had been involved in an altercation with a show producer and was suspended and later dropped from the show.  Although his actions were absolutely unacceptable, Clarkson is notorious for his overtly aggressive and vulgar personality bringing to question whether the BBC should have taken the action they did by firing Clarkson.  With the immense following Clarkson has, it has become a big debate calling the attention of people all around the world.
Although the article does contain aspects of the official style, there are obvious structural and fundamental signs of the plain style.  With one or two sentence paragraphs, and a simple, clear, and concise message, I can identify the plain style and the purpose of the plain style.  With the average readability grade level score around 10th grade, I would argue that the number of quotations and names of people and places contribute to the height of the number.  To reach the intended audience, I assume those who are/were fans of the show and Jeremy Clarkson, this article needed to be written in a style that would be accessible.  Naturally, the plain style seems to fit the bill.  
            Recognizing the fact that BBC’s “Top Gear” reaches nearly 350 million viewers, it is safe to say there is the interest of the audience to consider.  Deep within the article, there was an obvious bias in favor of Clarkson.  This report could have been objective or completely ignored the overarching opinion of the public, but it did not.  Why would an author choose this?  To please the audience, that’s why.  Through a small amount of research, it was apparent to me that the general public and viewers were siding with Clarkson.  As for appeal, the authors of the article decided on elements of the plain style to subtly takes sides.
            The first sentence/paragraph of the article was glaring.  Stated simply, “Jeremy Clarkson won't have his contract renewed as host of "Top Gear" after he apparently busted his producer's lip and verbally abused him, the BBC announced Wednesday.”  I would conclude that this statement is clear-cut and understandable initially.  Taking a closer look at the diction used, I was able to identify a word that changed my interpretation of this statement.  Apparently.  Looking at the word apparently and the impact it had on the sentence, it made me question whether this story about Clarkson being involved in a physical and verbal altercation actually even happened.  The word also conveys that this contract renewal decision by the BBC is based on an allegation, not pure, hard evidence.  It shifted the blame from Clarkson to the BBC, which heads the trail of bias.
            The following sentence begins with, “Clarkson, who hosted one of the most-watched television shows in the world…” How is this biased?  Well, there are countless ways that the authors could have used a qualifier in addressing Clarkson.  They could have made a statement regarding his bluntness and controversial commentary, but they chose not to.  When an audience member considers a phrase like, “hosted one of the most-watched television shows in the world,” no matter who is being described, there is power and credibility placed within them.
            This article also stated that “Clarkson made a number of attempts to apologize” which was directly followed by “BBC Director General Tony Hall issued a statement announcing Clarkson was being dropped.”  This order and lack of transition cause the audience to view the situation differently.  There is information missing between Clarkson’s numerous apologies and the reasoning behind the BBC’s decision to fire him.  Because this information is missing, it makes it easier for the audience to side with Clarkson, assuming that he apologized, and the BBC simply would not accept his apologies.  The way these two simple sentences were crafted created a clear and concise message, but were ambiguous when it came to the perspective of the BBC.
            Another very important aspect of this article that clearly demonstrated bias in favor of Clarkson were featured Tweets from various powerful sources.  There was a series of three tweets from Richard Hammond, Rupert Murdoch, and Jeremy Clarkson himself.  Richard Hammond continues as a member of Top Gear, and worked closely with Clarkson building a strong friendship.  Rupert Murdoch is a huge name in the media world, and incredibly successful in the field.  Hammond tweeted, “Gutted as such a sad end to an era.  We’re all three of us idiots in our different ways but it’s been an incredible ride together.”  The emotional connection and appeal furthers the questioning about whether the BBC made the right decision or not.  Murdoch tweeted, “How stupid can BBC be in firing Jeremy Clarkson?  Funny man with great expertise and huge following.”  If that doesn’t persuade an audience to think a certain way, having a man in the business with experience and great insight question the BBC, then I’m not sure what would convince the audience otherwise.  The final tweet is from Clarkson himself.  He said, “Many many thanks to all of the people who have called for my reinstatement.  I’m very touched.  We shall all learn next week what will happen.”  Clarkson sounds gracious and genuine addressing the concerns of his followers.  Not one tweet featured an opinion in opposition to Clarkson.  The use of exemplum in this case created an article in favor of Clarkson, especially with the insight of Murdoch.  The informality of the Twitter medium also contributed to the creation of the plain style, using it to discretely take the side of Clarkson and place the blame on the BBC.

            Initially, this article is an easy read explaining the situation.  Looking deeper, it’s apparent that there is bias throughout that sways the audience in the favor of Clarkson.  This specific example of the plain style demonstrated simple sentences and seemed clear cut and concise to appeal to the audience.  Without overtly stating that the BBC had made a huge mistake, the authors seemed to leave holes where the perspective of the BBC belonged.  The constant use of exemplum throughout, in which the authors provided justification for Clarkson’s actions, provides a better sense of Clarkson’s character which showed that he did participate in anything all too unexpected.  The informality of including Tweets also showed the plainness, yet the Tweets chosen were only in favor of Clarkson.  All of these aspects point to the use of the plain style to sway the audience to side with Clarkson, or to appeal to the expansive following Clarkson has.  One might ask for what other reasons CNN would publish an article with such bias?  This is something to think about when processing the context and spheres surrounding the issue.

KW

Mindfulness in Plain English


“That flowing, soft-focused moment of pure awareness is mindfulness.”
–Bhante Gunaratana

The term mindfulness is a broad one, with many different definitions and interpretations that have been taken up by diverse groups of people who use it in a seemingly endless range of applications.  Mindfulness pops up in a broad scope of human activities—from business and politics to education, psychology, neurobiology and Buddhist philosophy. The following is an attempt to situate the concept of mindfulness in two varying spheres of human activity in order to see how different prose styles changes the meaning and application of the concept of mindfulness.
For the purpose of this critique I’ll look at mindfulness in the context of the workplace and in the context of academia.  Although there are many similarities between the ways the concept of mindfulness can be applied to human activities, the workplace and academia are marked by definite differences in the style of language used to define mindfulness—Plain English vs. Official Style-- and the expected outcomes and effects of these definitions. 
            In the workplace, mindfulness is generally defined in Plain English for the purpose of simplifying the concept and making it something an employee can actually practice while working.  In this context, mindfulness becomes a tool that is used to create a harmonious working environment by re-teaching individuals how to interact with each other and the stresses of the workplace environment. 
            In an academic setting centered on the humanities, mindfulness is most often looked at from historical and philosophical points of view and is generally written about in the Official Style. In the academic context, mindfulness becomes less a tool for social activity, and more an abstract concept, situated in a Buddhist tradition.  Often times philosophical terminology is used to frame mindfulness within the discourses of Eastern and Western philosophy and history.
            Lets now look closer at the context of the workplace and consider how the prose style of Plain English is used to clarify the concept of mindfulness and present it as something that can be practiced in the workplace.
Google is one company that has taken up the concept of mindfulness and applied it to the workplace environment.  Chade-Meng Tan, the head of mindfulness training at Google, defines mindfulness as, “…developing self knowledge and self mastery.  By using {concentration}, we create a high-resolution perception into the cognitive and emotive processes.  It means being able to observe our thought-stream and the process of emotion with high clarity, objectivity, and from a third person perspective.”
In the above quote, taken from a TedTalk Chad-Meng Tan gave, he uses a number of Plain Style strategies to succinctly sum up the concept of mindfulness.  First, Tan uses the active voice to help illustrate the point that mindfulness is something an employee at Google can do: “By using concentration, we create a high resolution perception…” Tan also uses parallelism to qualify the verb “observe” in the following sentence: “It means being able to observe our thought stream and the process of emotion with high clarity, objectivity, and from a third person perspective.”  By using the pros strategy of parallelism, Tan is able to avoid long sentences, strung together by prepositional phrases and conjunctions.  In other words, Tan’s use of short sentences and clear subject–verb relationships make his sentences easy to read and comprehend. 
Bhante Henepola Gunaratana’s book “Mindfulness in Plain English” uses similar prose style strategies to illustrate the concept.  Although I’m not certain if Gunaratana’s book is used to train employees in the workplace, I think it would be a perfect text to do so.  I’ll continue by showing why “Mindfulness in Plain English” is a text that can be put into action in the workplace, and then contrast it with a more scholarly text on mindfulness. 
In “Mindfulness in Plain English”, Gunaratana defines mindfulness as,

“When you first become aware of something, there is a fleeting instant of pure awareness just before you conceptualize the thing, before you identify it. That is a state of awareness.  Ordinarily, this state is short-lived. It is that flashing split second just as you focus your eyes on the thing, just as you focus your mind on the thing, just before you objectify it, clamp down on it mentally, and segregate it from the rest of existence. It takes place just before you start thinking about it—before your mind says, “Oh, it’s a dog.” That flowing, soft-focused moment of pure awareness is mindfulness.”

            Although mindfulness is a highly abstract concept, Gunaratana describes it with simple prose that is easy to comprehend.  He begins his paragraph long description with a strong topic sentence.  This helps to define what information the following sentences will include.  He then lays the concept out in short sentences.  He avoids using very abstract words.  And, like Chad-Meng Tan he uses parallelism to organize his paragraph.  This clear and concise description of mindfulness can help the reader grasp an abstract concept.  The reader may even realize that they have experienced mindfulness before, without even knowing it. 
            Now we’ll look at another description of mindfulness by the Buddhist scholar T.P. Kasulis.  To clarify, ‘without-thinking’ is Kasulis’s term for mindfulness. 

            “Without-thinking is distinct from thinking and not-thinking precisely in its assuming no intentional attitude whatsoever: it neither affirms nor denies, accepts nor rejects, believes nor disbelieves.  In fact, it does not objectify either implicitly or explicitly.  In this respect, the noetic (or act aspect) of without-thinking is completely different from that of thinking or not-thinking.  Even though without thinking circumvents all objectification, it is nonetheless a mode of consciousness, and through reflection on a without-thinking act, one may isolate aspects of its formal contents.”

            As can be seen, Kasulis’s description of mindfulness is much more abstract.  Though he uses some Plain English strategies such as parallelism, his sentences are much longer and filled with specialized terminology.  For example, the term noetic is a philosophical term.  The terms ‘thinking’, ‘not-thinking’, and ‘without-thinking’ are derived from a 12th century Japanese Buddhist text by Dogen, who in turn borrowed those terms from older Chinese Buddhist texts. 
There are also implicit Buddhist ideas imbedded in Kasulis’s language that would probably seem strange to a reader unfamiliar with Buddhist thought.   For example, in his description, ‘without-thinking’ is the actor instead of an individual acting on his consciousness:  “Without-thinking is distinct from thinking and not-thinking precisely in its assuming no intentional attitude whatsoever: it neither affirms nor denies, accepts nor rejects, believes nor disbelieves”.   In this language there are implied Buddhist beliefs about the self, the nature of consciousness, and the idea of non-dualism that are essential to scholarly discourse on mindfulness.  Kasulis’s definition of mindfulness is participating in an ongoing philosophical and historical discourse that is extremely important in understanding Buddhism in the west.  But it is not very useful for the practical application of mindfulness.  For this, texts like Tan’s and Gunaratana’s are much more useful.
But the question begs to be asked, are the proponents of ‘workplace mindfulness’ talking about the same thing as actual Buddhists and Buddhist scholars?  A corporation like Google uses mindfulness as means to achieve goals that contradict many traditional Buddhist teachings.  As Chad-Meng Tan, the head of Google’s mindfulness program says, "I always align the qualities of peace, joy, and compassion with success and profits."  But in Buddhism, success and profits are seen as negative goals that perpetuate human attachments and suffering in the world. 
            Does talking about mindfulness in Plain English only serve to water down a richly complex concept that belongs to century long traditions?  Does talking about mindfulness in the Official Style reserve a powerful tool for social harmony for only a few well-read scholars and Buddhist practitioners?  I’d like to suggest the Buddhist concept of the Middle Path.  Instead of taking either extreme, it is possible that talking about mindfulness in both Plain English and the Official Style work in their proper contexts. 
            

Shakespeare Schmooped

by Zachary Olson

You use the Plain Style. It's everywhere: a Facebook post, a text to your friend, a note you write to yourself so you don’t forget something later. The Plain Style is meant to be understandable, and it's even used to describe things that aren’t meant to be understandable. It’s thought of as an effective method of communication.
But what does plain style do, and how does it do it? In order to answer these questions, two pieces of work will be compared: Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare and the famous tragedy’s summary on Schmoop.com. I have chosen to analyze the first two paragraphs of Schmoop’s summary, and the prologue of Romeo and Juliet because theyre similar in length. But besides length, there’s nothing similar about these two, as shown by the side-by-side comparison of the two.
                                                                                   
                       


Romeo and Juliet- Prologue

Two households, both alike in dignity,
In fair Verona, where we lay our scene,
From ancient grudge break to new mutiny,
Where civil blood makes civil hands unclean.
From forth the fatal loins of these two foes
A pair of star-cross'd lovers take their life;
Whose misadventured piteous overthrows
Do with their death bury their parents' strife.
The fearful passage of their death-mark'd love,
And the continuance of their parents' rage,
Which, but their children's end, nought could remove,
Is now the two hours' traffic of our stage;
The which if you with patient ears attend,
What here shall miss, our toil shall strive to mend.

Romeo and Juliet- Summary
We start off with a little action: a duel between the servants of two enemy families of Verona: the Montagues and the Capulets. Exciting! After the swords are sheathed, Verona's Prince shows up to say that the next person who fights is going to get killed, and he means it this time.
Along comes Romeo Montague, mooning over some chick named Rosaline. Meanwhile, Juliet Capulet, age thirteen, has just heard that Verona's most eligible bachelor Paris has his eye on her. They're going to check each other out that night at a masquerade ball at the Capulets' house. (At least it's parentally sanctioned child abuse.) Romeo and his friends have decided to crash the Capulet ball—in costume—because Rosaline is on the guest list.


Summary

67.9

Readability Formula
Grade
7.4
9.5
9.4
6.9
6
Average Grade Level
7.8




Prologue





58.8

Readability Formula
Grade
14.3
17.3
10.7
9.5
18.2
Average Grade Level
14.0




It’s not surprising to see that the summary is statistically easier to read than Romeo and Juliet. And from these readability measurements, we also see the summary successfully target what would be thought of as the desired reading grade level, the average for an American: 7th grade. But Romeo and Juliet doesn’t hit that grade level. This is largely because Shakespeare wasn’t developing any of his pieces using modern English, which is what the readability calculator is judging off of. But, first, how reliable are readability scores? And second, and more importantly, is a work of art like Romeo and Juliet meant to be calculated and summarized?
To be blunt: no, it's not. Romeo and Juliet wasn’t meant to be read quickly under duress without any available reflection time. Shakespeare didn’t write his words to be skimmed, just as every great novelist doesn’t. The apparent difficulty reading this play, as indicated by the readability score, is intentional from the author.
But lets say you remembered you have a book report due in the morning on Romeo and Juliet. And you think to yourself “there’s no way I can read that whole play in one night. It's Flesh-Kincaid Reading Ease is 9.1 points lower than the summary!” Why not quickly get the gist of what the book is about, so you can write an accurate book report? This is the beauty of Schmoop: it lends a helping hand to procrastinating students.
So is the plain style valuable? Is it necessary? Is it ethical? I know many students that would aggressively nod their head at those questions. Students cram: sometimes by necessity, sometimes as a product of procrastination. But it's not just students, everyone crams. There aren’t enough hours in a day to sit down and fully invest yourself in whatever you heart desires that day. But is cramming affecting how we understand literature? And what does this say about summaries?
The summary disengages itself from the pieces it's summarizing. What a summary does is not shorten the prose. It doesn’t just restate powerful quotes or important information. It extracts identity. The summarizer could have written his summary in Shakespearian prose, beginning the passage with “mine apologies, but this summary wilt not beest effective the slightest bit.” He could have given the reader at least some sense of Romeo and Juliet but he didn’t. In fact, if he’s responsible for anything, it's taking out everything Shakespearian from the play.
He added his own twist, using a conversational, easy-to-read writing voice. And this is to be expected; the job of the summarizer is to deliver the meaning of something in the most condensed, easily understandable way. This particular Schmoop summarizer uses the plain style to communicate more effectively by removing the identity of Romeo and Juliet and adding his own.
Maybe plain style takes away from the beauty of eloquent prose. But also, maybe it’s doing the exact opposite. Maybe it's drawing in wider crowds of people, not just everyone lucky enough to be able to read at the 14th grade level (the grade level that Romeo and Juliet was written at). To many, the “beauty” of eloquent prose lies not just in the writing itself, but also in the meaning behind the words. If plain style can communicate effectively to the most people, a summary of a piece of literature isn’t extracting from the beauty of the piece, it's spreading that beauty to wider audiences.